Spot Logical Fallacies and Weak Arguments in Any Opinion Piece

Returns a ranked table that quotes each weak passage in an essay, names the fallacy, explains in one line why it fails, and suggests evidence that would fix it.

You getMain claim, table with columns and strongest points

Prompt

Prompt
You are a critical-thinking instructor who teaches argument analysis to university students.

I will paste an opinion piece or essay right after this message. Read all of it, then find the logical fallacies and weak arguments in it.

Rules:
1. Quote each problematic passage exactly, in quotation marks, using no more than two sentences. Do not paraphrase.
2. Name the specific fallacy or weakness, such as hasty generalization, false dilemma or unsupported causal claim. If it does not fit a named fallacy, label it "weak support" and say why.
3. Explain why it fails in one sentence tied to this passage, not a textbook definition.
4. For each issue, describe the kind of evidence or reasoning that would make the point stronger. Do not invent statistics, studies or sources.
5. Rank issues from most to least damaging to the main argument and skip minor style nitpicks. Also name the piece's strongest points so the review is fair.

Output format:
1. Main claim: one sentence restating the author's thesis.
2. Table with columns: # | Quoted passage | Fallacy or weakness | Why it fails | What would strengthen it
3. Strongest points: 1-2 bullets.
4. Overall verdict: 2-3 sentences on how well the argument holds up.

End with one line listing any claims you could not judge without checking outside facts.

Example output

Example for: a 700-word local newspaper op-ed arguing the fictional city of Millbrook should ban rental e-scooters.

1. Main claim

Millbrook should ban rental e-scooters because they make streets more dangerous and add nothing to local transport.

2. Issues ranked by impact
#Quoted passageFallacy or weaknessWhy it failsWhat would strengthen it
1"Since the scooters arrived last spring, pedestrian injuries downtown have risen. The link could not be clearer."Post hoc (false cause)A rise after the scooters arrived does not show the scooters caused it, since construction, traffic or reporting changes could also explain it.Hospital or police records showing how many injuries actually involved scooters, compared with the year before.
2"Either we ban them now or we accept that someone will die on Main Street."False dilemmaIt ignores middle options like speed caps, parking zones or helmet rules.An explanation of why less drastic rules were tried or would not work.
3"I have personally seen three riders run red lights this month alone."Hasty generalization / anecdoteThree sightings by one person cannot show how most riders behave.Traffic-camera or city enforcement data on scooter violations versus cyclists and drivers.
4"Nobody I know uses these things to get to work."Weak support (biased sample)The author's social circle is not a representative sample of riders.Trip data from the operator showing trip times, lengths and peak hours.
5"Supporters of the scooters are mostly tech companies chasing profit."Ad hominem (circumstantial)Who backs a policy says nothing about whether its benefits are real.Address the actual arguments supporters make, such as reduced short car trips.
3. Strongest points
  • The point that scooters left on narrow sidewalks block wheelchair users is specific, observable and directly tied to public safety.
  • The note that the city signed the operator contract without a public hearing is a fair procedural concern that stands on its own.
4. Overall verdict

The piece raises two real problems, sidewalk clutter and a rushed contract, but its central safety claim rests on timing and personal observation rather than evidence. As written, it supports stricter regulation better than it supports a full ban. Adding injury data and addressing middle-ground options would make it far more persuasive.

Could not judge without outside facts: whether downtown pedestrian injuries actually rose, and the claimed 40% drop in bus ridership.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Exact quotes force the model to point at real text, so you can verify each claim instead of trusting a vague summary.
  • Ranking by damage to the main argument keeps the output focused on what matters, not on minor wording issues.
  • Asking for strongest points and fixable evidence makes the review fair and useful rather than a one-sided takedown.

Use before sharing, citing or replying to an op-ed, essay or blog post. Paste the full text right after the prompt in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. It also works for checking your own draft.

Common edits

  • Ask it to review your own essay draft and rewrite each flagged sentence with a stronger version.
  • Limit the table to the top three issues for a quick read before sharing an article on social media.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Research