Check Whether a Statistic or Chart in an Article Is Used Honestly
Runs a six-point checklist on a statistic or chart you paste (base rate, denominator, timeframe, axis, range, causation) and rewrites the claim accurately.
You getClaim as stated, checklist table and biggest problem
Prompt
You are a data journalist who fact-checks how numbers and charts are used in news articles.
Right after this message I will paste a statistic, a chart description or an article excerpt, plus the source link if I have one. Check whether the number is used honestly, then rewrite the claim so it is accurate.
Rules:
1. Run every item on this checklist and mark each one Pass, Problem or Can't tell: base rate, denominator, timeframe, axis and scale tricks, cherry-picked range, correlation vs causation.
2. For every Problem, quote the exact words or chart element and explain the issue in one or two sentences.
3. Do not invent missing figures or sources. If you need data I didn't give, name it and say where it would normally be found, such as the original survey or agency table.
4. Keep the rewritten claim to one or two plain sentences, with no wording stronger than the evidence supports.
5. If I pasted only a description of a chart, say which checks need the actual image.
Output format:
- Claim as stated (one line)
- Checklist table: Check | Verdict | What I found
- Biggest problem (2-3 sentences)
- Accurate rewrite
- Questions to ask the source (up to 3)
End with one line on what you could not verify and how confident you are overall.Example output
Tips and common edits
Why this works
- A fixed six-item checklist stops the model from catching only the obvious flaw and missing quieter ones like denominators or truncated axes.
- The 'Can't tell' verdict and the ban on inventing figures keep the check honest when data is missing.
- Requiring an accurate rewrite turns criticism into a usable sentence you can quote or share.
Use when a headline number or chart seems too dramatic. Paste the excerpt, any figures in the chart, and the link into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Extra context like totals or methods notes improves the verdicts.
Common edits
- Add checks for survey sample size and margin of error when the number comes from a poll.
- Ask for a short reply you could post under the article or send to the editor.
Make it repeatable
Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.
Prompt details
- By
- Prompts-GPT editors
- Published
Did this prompt work?
Keep exploring
More like this
Check a Website's Reliability with Lateral Reading Before You Cite It
Get a five-point lateral reading check of any site or organization, with search steps to verify each point and a clear cite, cite-with-caution or avoid verdict.
Check Whether a Health Headline Matches the Study Behind It
Paste a headline and its study abstract to get a 1-5 accuracy score, a check table on study design and risk figures, and a plain-English rewrite.
Fact-Check a Viral Post or Forwarded Message Claim by Claim Before Sharing
Splits a viral post into separate claims, rates each one, and gives you exact search phrases and source types to confirm or debunk it before you share.
Break Down a News Article into Facts, Opinions and Loaded Wording
Paste any news article and get a table of quoted claims labeled verifiable, interpretation or unattributed, plus loaded words, missing context and a pre-share checklist.
Source Credibility Check with Claim-by-Claim Verification Plan
Lists every factual claim in a pasted article or claim, rates the evidence for each and says exactly what to verify and where.
Compare How Different Articles Report the Same News Event
Get a side-by-side table showing which facts all your pasted articles agree on, where they conflict, what each leaves out, and how each frames the story.
- Spot Logical Fallacies and Weak Arguments in Any Opinion Piece
- Build a Verification Checklist for AI Answers and Their Citations
- Trace a Quote or Claim Back to Its Original Source Step by Step
- Interpret P-Values, Effect Sizes and Confidence Intervals in Plain English
- Symptom Notes to Possible Causes, Red Flags and When to Get Care
- Build a Literature Review Matrix from Pasted Abstracts with Gaps and Contradictions