Build a Verification Checklist for AI Answers and Their Citations

Paste any AI-generated answer and get a table of every claim and citation, rated by risk, with red flags and the exact check needed to verify each one.

You getClaim table with columns, top 5 checks to do first and claims too vague to verify as written

Prompt

Prompt
You are a research librarian who audits AI-generated text before it goes into reports, articles or papers.

I will paste an AI-generated answer right after this message. Build a verification checklist for it. Do not confirm or deny claims from memory. Your job is to flag each claim and tell me how to check it.

Rules:
1. Extract every factual claim, number, date, name, quote and citation as its own row, quoted or closely paraphrased.
2. Rate each row High, Medium or Low risk. Any citation with authors, journal, DOI or page numbers, any direct quote, and any exact statistic or date is automatically High.
3. For each row, name the specific check: where to look (Google Scholar, Crossref DOI lookup, publisher site, official statistics office, original transcript) and what details must match.
4. Note red flags of fabrication: malformed DOIs, suspiciously round numbers, quotes with no venue or date, author and journal pairings that look unlikely.
5. Do not suggest replacement sources or rewrite the text.

Output format:
- Claim table with columns: #, Claim or citation, Type, Risk, Red flags, How to verify, Status (left blank)
- Top 5 checks to do first, in order
- Claims too vague to verify as written

End with one line on what this checklist cannot catch, such as a real source being quietly misrepresented.

Example output

Example for: a 180-word AI answer on remote work and productivity, pasted by a student drafting a policy essay.

Claim Table

#Claim or citationTypeRiskRed flagsHow to verifyStatus
1"Remote workers are 13% more productive"StatisticHighExact figure with no source attached in textSearch the figure plus "working from home" in Google Scholar; find the original study and confirm sample and setting
2Hallworth, J. & Peng, L. (2021). Journal of Labor Dynamics, 44(3), 211-229CitationHighJournal name not familiar; check it existsSearch journal title in a library catalogue, then look up volume 44 issue 3 table of contents
3DOI 10.1093/jld/2021.0447CitationHighSuffix format unusual for this publisherPaste into doi.org; confirm it resolves to the same title and authors
4"Flexibility is the new salary," said a Microsoft executive in 2022QuoteHighNo name, venue or date beyond yearSearch exact phrase in quotes; find a transcript or press release with speaker named
5Remote work rose sharply after March 2020General claimLowNoneCheck any national labour statistics office release for 2020
658% of US workers can work remotely at least one day a weekStatisticHighPrecise figure, survey not namedSearch figure plus "survey"; confirm publisher, year and question wording
7Studies show hybrid teams report less burnoutGeneral claimMedium"Studies show" with no study namedLook for a systematic review on hybrid work and burnout

Top 5 Checks First

  1. Row 3: resolve the DOI (30 seconds, confirms or kills row 2)
  2. Row 2: confirm the journal and issue exist
  3. Row 4: trace the quote to a named speaker
  4. Row 1: find the original study behind 13%
  5. Row 6: identify the survey and its year

Too Vague to Verify as Written

  • Row 7: "studies show" needs a named study or should be cut
  • Row 4: "a Microsoft executive" cannot be checked without a name

This checklist cannot catch a real source that exists but says something different from how the AI summarized it; read the relevant section yourself.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Telling the model not to verify from memory stops it from confidently 'confirming' its own hallucinations.
  • Auto-rating citations, quotes and exact stats as High risk targets the exact places AI fabrication usually happens.
  • A blank Status column and a ranked top-5 list turn the output into a working checklist, not just commentary.

Use before citing anything ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini wrote for you. Have the full AI answer ready to paste, including its reference list. Works best on answers with citations, stats or quotes.

Common edits

  • Add a column for the APA or MLA citation as it should appear once verified.
  • Ask it to only list High risk rows when the pasted answer is long.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Research