Source Credibility Check with Claim-by-Claim Verification Plan

Lists every factual claim in a pasted article or claim, rates the evidence for each and says exactly what to verify and where.

You get: A research summary

More like this

The prompt

source-credibility-check-with-claim-by-claim-verification-plan.md
Act as a fact-checking editor. I will paste an article or a claim. Do not say you checked live sources unless you have web browsing; if you can't browse, rate only what the text itself supports and give me search queries to run. Rules: split the text into separate, checkable factual claims and ignore opinions; rate evidence for each as Strong, Mixed, Weak or None based on what the text cites (primary data, named experts, studies with dates, or anonymous or no sourcing); never mark a claim true or false without a source; call out vague wording, missing dates, cherry-picked statistics and circular sourcing. Output: 1) Claims table with number, claim, evidence cited, rating, problem. 2) Missing or weak sources. 3) Verification plan: for each Weak or None claim, the exact thing to check, the best primary source type or named publisher to check it at (official statistics, court records, original study, company filing) and one search query. 4) Overall credibility verdict in two sentences, with unanswered questions. Text: {paste article or claim here}

Example output

AI-written example

Note: I can't browse, so ratings reflect only what the text itself cites. Nothing below is marked true or false.

1) Claims table

#ClaimEvidence citedRatingProblem
1Maple County's four-day school week raised math scores 18%"A recent study"WeakNo author, date, or publisher. It doesn't say whether 18% is points or relative change, or which grades and years.
2The district saved $2.1 million in its first yearSuperintendent quoteMixedNamed source, but an interested party. No budget document cited, and it doesn't say whether the figure is gross or net of added costs.
3Teacher turnover fell by half"Officials say"NoneNo baseline, time span, or numbers.
4Four-day weeks are now used in "hundreds of districts nationwide"NoneNoneVague quantity, no date, no source.
5Absenteeism fell from 14% to 9%District annual report, 2022–23StrongPrimary document named with a year, but the comparison year isn't given.
6The study "confirms" the schedule worksSame unnamed studyWeakCircular: it restates claim 1 and treats it as independent confirmation.

2) Missing or weak sources

  • The study in claims 1 and 6 is never identified.
  • Claims 2 and 3 rely on the district's own statements.
  • Claim 4 has no sourcing at all.
  • Scores are given for one year, so cherry-picking is possible. The text doesn't mention other years or comparison districts.

3) Verification plan

  • Claim 1: Find the original study and check the metric, sample, years, and whether it had a comparison group.

    • Source type: peer-reviewed paper or state education department assessment data.
    • Query: Maple County four-day school week math scores study
  • Claim 3: Get staff counts and separations for several consecutive years.

    • Source type: district HR or board reports, plus state teacher workforce data.
    • Query: Maple County school district teacher turnover rate 2021 2024 board report
  • Claim 4: Check a current count of districts on shortened weeks.

    • Source type: state education agencies or a national education statistics center.
    • Query: number of school districts four-day week by state 2024
  • Claim 6: Resolves once claim 1's study is found. Then check whether anyone independent has replicated it.

    • Query: four-day school week achievement systematic review
  • Claim 2 (optional): Compare the superintendent's figure with the adopted budget and audit.

    • Source type: district financial statements.
    • Query: Maple County school district annual financial report transportation savings

4) Overall verdict
The article is only partly credible. One claim has a named primary source, while its headline claims rest on an unnamed study and statements from interested officials. Unanswered questions: What is the study, and does it have a control group? What time periods and baselines apply to the turnover and savings figures?

Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Paste the full article or the exact claim, plus the link and publication date if you have them. Use it before sharing or citing something.

Questions about this prompt

More in Research

Competitor Landscape Scan with Source-Backed Citation Table

Runs a structured competitor scan that starts with search queries, ranks sources by reliability, and ends with a cited comparison table and a positioning recommendation.

Customer Voice Synthesis from Reviews and Forum Threads

Turns pasted reviews, support threads, and forum posts into coded themes, representative evidence, and a ranked list of product or messaging decisions.

Market Size Triangulation: Top-Down vs Bottom-Up with Source Grading

Builds a transparent market size estimate from discoverable sources, compares top-down and bottom-up methods, and flags weak assumptions before a go or no-go call.

Pre-Interview Company Brief with Dated News and Smart Questions

Produces a one-page interview brief with dated, linked recent news, the company's likely priorities and five sharp questions to ask.

Software Vendor Due Diligence Brief with Cited Evidence Review

Guides a vendor shortlist review: finds primary sources like docs, security pages, and pricing, scores vendors on your criteria, and flags risks and open questions before purchase.

Fact-Check Research Brief for an Explainer or Documentary Video

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence review, and citation table for a video's factual claims so a producer can decide which claims to keep, soften, or cut before scripting.

Contract and Lease Plain-English Clause Review

Explains each clause of a pasted contract or lease in plain English, flags one-sided terms and lists questions to ask before signing.

Lab Results Plain-English Explainer with Doctor Questions

Explains each pasted lab value and its reference range in plain English and ends with questions to bring to your doctor, without diagnosing.

Paper Breakdown for Students with Seminar Questions

Breaks a pasted paper abstract or text into claim, method, key evidence and limitations, then adds three seminar discussion questions.

Parallel Research Fan-Out and Fan-In with Citation Table and Decision Memo

Splits a research question across parallel research agents, defines source discovery and evidence review steps, merges findings into a citation table, and produces a decision memo without claiming live browsing.

Research Question Narrower for Student Assignments

Turns a broad topic into five researchable questions sized to your assignment, each with the data or sources it needs.

AI Paper Explainer with Evidence Table and Practical Takeaways

Turns a pasted AI paper abstract or text into a plain-language explanation of what is new, how it was tested, its limits and what to do with it.