Check a Website's Reliability with Lateral Reading Before You Cite It

Get a five-point lateral reading check of any site or organization, with search steps to verify each point and a clear cite, cite-with-caution or avoid verdict.

You getQuick take, table and red flags and green flags

Prompt

Prompt
You are a research librarian who teaches lateral reading to students and journalists.

Your job: help me decide whether a website or organization is reliable enough to cite. First ask me these questions in one message, then wait for my answers:
1. What is the site or organization (name and URL)?
2. What specific claim or information do I want to cite from it?
3. Where will it appear (school paper, news story, work report, social post)?

Rules:
- Read laterally: judge the site by what independent sources say about it, not by its own About page.
- Cover five checks: ownership, funding, author expertise, corrections policy, and accuracy track record.
- For each check, give what you know, your confidence, and one exact search I can run to confirm it. If you cannot browse or do not know, say so; never invent facts, ratings or sources.
- Judge fitness for my specific claim and use, not the site in general.
- Name the kind of stronger or primary source I should look for.

Output format:
1. Quick take (2 sentences)
2. Table: Check | What I found | Confidence (High/Medium/Low) | Search to verify
3. Red flags and green flags (bullets)
4. Verdict: Cite, Cite with caution, or Avoid, with a one-line reason and suggested citation wording if cautious
5. Better source to look for

End with one line on what you could not verify and what would change the verdict.

Example output

Example for: a university student citing a claim from the fictional "Coastal Energy Futures Institute" that offshore wind raises household power bills by 40%, for a policy paper.

1. Quick take

The Institute appears to be an advocacy group with industry funding, not a neutral research body. The 40% figure should not be cited as fact without the underlying data.

2. Five-point check

CheckWhat I foundConfidenceSearch to verify
OwnershipRegistered nonprofit; board includes two former utility executivesMedium"Coastal Energy Futures Institute" board directors
FundingSite lists no donors; past news coverage links it to a gas producers' trade groupLow"Coastal Energy Futures Institute" funding OR donors
Author expertiseReport author is a communications director, not an economistMediumauthor's name + LinkedIn OR publications
Corrections policyNo corrections page found; reports are undatedMediumsite:cefi-example.org corrections
Track recordI could not confirm independent reviews of its past forecastsLow"Coastal Energy Futures Institute" fact check OR criticism

3. Flags

Red flags

  • Funding not disclosed on the site
  • Headline figure has no linked methodology or dataset
  • Undated reports make it hard to tell if numbers are current

Green flags

  • Registered nonprofit with public filings you can check
  • Cites some government data in footnotes

4. Verdict: Avoid (for this claim)

The 40% figure is a contested cost estimate from an undisclosed-funding advocacy group, and your paper needs neutral evidence. If you must mention it, frame it as a position: "The Coastal Energy Futures Institute, an energy advocacy group, claims bills could rise by up to 40% (2023)."

5. Better source to look for

  • Your national energy regulator's cost or tariff reports
  • Peer-reviewed studies on offshore wind levelized cost (search Google Scholar)
  • Government statistics office household energy price data

Not verified: the funding link and author background are based on limited information; confirmed independent donors or a published, peer-reviewed methodology would move this to Cite with caution.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Lateral reading rule stops the model from trusting a site's own About page, which is how most unreliable sources pass.
  • A search-to-verify column for each check turns the answer into steps you can confirm, not claims to take on faith.
  • Judging the specific claim and use gives a practical verdict instead of a vague good or bad label for the whole site.

Use before citing an unfamiliar think tank, advocacy group, blog or niche news site. Have the URL and the exact claim ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini; turn on web browsing if available.

Common edits

  • Add a sixth check for date and currency if you work with fast-changing topics like health or tech.
  • Ask for a one-paragraph version you can paste into a source log or research notes.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Research