Paper Breakdown for Students with Seminar Questions

Breaks a pasted paper abstract or text into claim, method, key evidence and limitations, then adds three seminar discussion questions.

You get: A text answer

More like this

The prompt

paper-breakdown-for-students-with-seminar-questions.md
Act as a graduate teaching assistant who helps students read research papers critically. I will paste an abstract or text. If I haven't said my course or level, ask one short question first. Rules: use only what is in the text and mark anything you infer as Inference; never invent numbers, sample sizes or results; explain jargon in brackets the first time it appears; separate what the authors claim from what the evidence actually shows. Output: 1) Claim: one or two sentences. 2) Method: design, sample, data and analysis in 3 bullets. 3) Key evidence: the 2-3 strongest findings with any numbers given. 4) Limitations: stated by the authors, and any further ones you can see, labeled separately. 5) Three seminar discussion questions, each one with a short note on why it opens a good debate. 6) What the text did not tell you, such as full methods or effect sizes. Text: {paste paper abstract or text here}

Example output

AI-written example

1) Claim
Delaying school start times by 45 minutes for four weeks led to longer sleep and better maths test scores among 15-16-year-olds. The authors suggest later starts could be a low-cost way to support learning.

2) Method

  • Design: Quasi-experimental [groups were not assigned by chance] comparison of six schools. Three delayed their start by 45 minutes and three kept their usual times.
  • Sample: 214 students aged 15-16.
  • Data and analysis: Sleep diaries kept by students and an end-of-term maths test. Groups were compared on average sleep time and test scores, with scores expressed in SD [standard deviation, a unit of spread that makes scores comparable].

3) Key evidence

  • Students at delayed-start schools slept 32 minutes longer per night on average.
  • Their maths scores were 0.21 SD higher (95% CI [confidence interval, the range of plausible true values] 0.04 to 0.38).
  • Self-reported mood did not differ between groups.

Claim vs. evidence: The authors frame the result as a benefit for learning. The evidence shows an association in six schools, and the confidence interval is wide, so the effect could be very small.

4) Limitations
Stated by the authors:

  • Short intervention (four weeks).
  • Sleep was self-reported.

Further limitations (Inference):

  • Schools were not randomly assigned, so the groups may have differed in other ways, such as teaching quality or intake.
  • Six schools is a small number of clusters [groups of students sharing an environment].
  • Students and teachers could not be blind to the condition, so expectations or the Hawthorne effect [behaving differently because you know you are being studied] may have played a part.
  • One test in one subject limits how far the result generalizes.

5) Seminar discussion questions

  1. If students had been randomly assigned to schools, what would you expect to change in the results?
    Why it works: It gets students weighing the strengths and weaknesses of quasi-experiments against randomized trials.
  2. Is a 0.21 SD gain large enough to justify changing a school's timetable?
    Why it works: It separates statistical significance from practical importance, and costs and benefits invite disagreement.
  3. Why might mood not change even though sleep increased?
    Why it works: Students can debate measurement problems against a real lack of effect, and what else might need measuring.

6) What the text did not tell you

  • Whether the analysis accounted for students being clustered within schools.
  • How the schools were chosen, and how similar they were at baseline.
  • Whether the maths
Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Paste an abstract or a section of a paper before a seminar. For a fuller breakdown, paste the methods and results sections too.

Questions about this prompt

More in Research

Competitor Landscape Scan with Source-Backed Citation Table

Runs a structured competitor scan that starts with search queries, ranks sources by reliability, and ends with a cited comparison table and a positioning recommendation.

Contract and Lease Plain-English Clause Review

Explains each clause of a pasted contract or lease in plain English, flags one-sided terms and lists questions to ask before signing.

Customer Voice Synthesis from Reviews and Forum Threads

Turns pasted reviews, support threads, and forum posts into coded themes, representative evidence, and a ranked list of product or messaging decisions.

Lab Results Plain-English Explainer with Doctor Questions

Explains each pasted lab value and its reference range in plain English and ends with questions to bring to your doctor, without diagnosing.

Market Size Triangulation: Top-Down vs Bottom-Up with Source Grading

Builds a transparent market size estimate from discoverable sources, compares top-down and bottom-up methods, and flags weak assumptions before a go or no-go call.

Pre-Interview Company Brief with Dated News and Smart Questions

Produces a one-page interview brief with dated, linked recent news, the company's likely priorities and five sharp questions to ask.

Research Question Narrower for Student Assignments

Turns a broad topic into five researchable questions sized to your assignment, each with the data or sources it needs.

Software Vendor Due Diligence Brief with Cited Evidence Review

Guides a vendor shortlist review: finds primary sources like docs, security pages, and pricing, scores vendors on your criteria, and flags risks and open questions before purchase.

Source Credibility Check with Claim-by-Claim Verification Plan

Lists every factual claim in a pasted article or claim, rates the evidence for each and says exactly what to verify and where.

Brutally Honest Red Team for Your Plan or Idea

Stress-tests a plan with five strong objections, hidden assumptions, the likeliest failure path and the evidence that would change the verdict.

Exam Prep Study Plan with Weekly Schedule, Practice Targets, and Risk Review

Creates a realistic study plan for an upcoming exam based on topics, current confidence, and available hours. It outputs a weekly schedule, practice targets, and a checkpoint to decide where to shift effort.

Fact-Check Research Brief for an Explainer or Documentary Video

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence review, and citation table for a video's factual claims so a producer can decide which claims to keep, soften, or cut before scripting.