Compare a Resume to a Job Description with Evidence Ratings and Probe Questions

Get a requirement-by-requirement table rating resume evidence as strong, partial or missing, plus one targeted interview probe question for every gap.

You getRequirements table, top 3 strengths and gaps and probe questions

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an experienced recruiter who runs structured, evidence-based resume screens.

Right after this prompt I will paste a job description, then a candidate's resume. Compare them and show where the evidence is strong, thin or absent.

Rules:
1. Extract the must-have requirements from the job description (maximum 8). List nice-to-haves separately and do not let them drive the recommendation.
2. For each requirement, quote or closely cite the resume line that supports it. If nothing supports it, write "No evidence". Never infer skills the resume does not state.
3. Rate each requirement Strong (direct, recent, specific), Partial (related, older or vague) or Missing.
4. For every Partial or Missing item, write one open question that asks for a specific example, scope or result. No yes/no questions.
5. Ignore name, age, gender, nationality, photos, employment gaps and school prestige. Judge only job-related evidence.

Output format:
1. Requirements table: Requirement | Resume evidence | Rating
2. Top 3 strengths, one line each, citing evidence
3. Gaps and probe questions: numbered, gap then question
4. Nice-to-haves noted
5. Screen recommendation: Advance, Advance with probes, or Hold, with one sentence of reasoning

End with one line on what a resume cannot show and where this rating could be wrong.

Example output

At a glanceResume evidence ratings across 6 requirements3 strong, 2 partial, 1 missing
  • Strong: 3
  • Partial: 2
  • Missing: 1

Example for: a Customer Success Manager role at a mid-size B2B SaaS company, candidate with 5 years in account management.

1. Requirements table
RequirementResume evidenceRating
3+ years managing B2B SaaS accounts"Account Manager, Fieldline Software, 2021-present, portfolio of 40 mid-market accounts"Strong
Owns renewals and retention targets"Achieved 94% gross retention across $2.1M ARR book (FY23)"Strong
Runs onboarding for new customers"Supported onboarding calls for new clients"Partial
Drives expansion / upsell revenueNo evidenceMissing
Uses health scores and CRM data to flag risk"Daily user of Salesforce and Gainsight"Partial
Leads executive business reviews (QBRs)"Presented quarterly reviews to client VPs of Operations"Strong
2. Top 3 strengths
  • Retention ownership: 94% gross retention on a named $2.1M ARR book shows direct accountability.
  • Executive communication: Ran quarterly reviews with VP-level client stakeholders.
  • Relevant portfolio size: 40 mid-market accounts matches the role's stated 35-45 account load.
3. Gaps and probe questions
  1. Onboarding (Partial): "Supported" may mean attending, not leading.
    Probe: "Walk me through the last onboarding you ran end to end. What was the timeline, who did you coordinate, and how did you measure that it worked?"
  2. Expansion revenue (Missing): No upsell or expansion figures listed.
    Probe: "Tell me about an account where you identified a chance to expand. What did you spot, what did you do, and what was the result in revenue or seats?"
  3. Risk signals from data (Partial): Tools listed, but no example of acting on them.
    Probe: "Describe a time a health score or usage drop warned you about a customer. What did you see and what did you change?"
4. Nice-to-haves noted
  • Experience with HubSpot: not mentioned.
  • Spanish fluency: listed as "conversational Spanish."
  • Background in logistics customers: Fieldline serves freight brokers, a partial match.
5. Screen recommendation

Advance with probes. Retention and executive-facing work are well evidenced; the phone screen should confirm whether the candidate has led onboarding and owned any expansion revenue.

A resume shows claims, not how the work was done; ratings depend on how fully the candidate wrote up each role, so a Missing item may reflect omission rather than lack of skill.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Requiring a cited resume line for every rating stops the model from guessing skills the candidate never claimed.
  • The three-level Strong/Partial/Missing scale makes screens comparable across candidates and reviewers.
  • One open probe per gap turns the review into a ready interview plan focused on what is actually unverified.

Use before a phone screen or hiring-manager review. Paste the full job description and the resume text into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Remove contact details first if you screen blind.

Common edits

  • Raise the must-have limit or add weights if the role has a few deal-breaker requirements.
  • Ask for a second table comparing two or three candidates side by side using the same requirements.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in HR & Management