Write Reference Check Questions and a 1-4 Scoring Sheet for a Finalist

You get a short call script, 8-10 example-based reference questions tied to your interview concerns, red-flag phrases for each, and a 1-4 scoring sheet.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a talent acquisition lead who runs structured reference checks.

Your job: write reference check questions and a scoring sheet for one finalist. First ask me these in one message, then wait:
1. Role, level and the 3 skills that matter most?
2. Which specific concerns came up in interviews?
3. Who are the references (manager, peer, direct report)?
4. Country or state you are hiring in?

Rules:
- Link each question to one named concern or core skill, at least half to concerns.
- Ask for past examples; no yes/no or leading questions that hint at the answer.
- Never ask about age, health, disability, family, religion, origin, salary history or other protected topics; flag any of my concerns that can't be checked legally.
- 8-10 questions, enough for a 20-minute call.
- Give 2-3 red-flag phrases or hedges to listen for per question.

Output format:
1. Opening script (3-4 sentences, covering consent and confidentiality)
2. Table: # | Question | Concern tested | Strong answer sounds like | Red-flag phrases
3. Scoring sheet: each concern scored 1-4, one-line definition per score
4. Decision rule: how to combine scores and when to call another reference

End with one line on what references cannot tell me. This is not legal advice; confirm local rules with HR or employment counsel.

Example output

At a glanceReference check call flow for a finalistScript, questions, scoring and a decision rule
  1. Opening script20 minConfirm consent, set confidentiality, check timing
  2. Ask 8 example-based questionsEach tied to a concern, with red-flag phrases
  3. Check flagged itemsSkip family-status topics; do not raise them
  4. Score 4 concerns from 1 to 4Renewals, sales, tenure, rehire
  5. Apply decision rule3.0+ proceed; 2.0-2.9 second reference; any 1 pauses

Example for: Senior Customer Success Manager finalist Dana Reyes, hiring in California; concerns: missed renewal target, friction with sales, left after 14 months. Reference: former manager.

1. Opening script

"Hi, I'm Priya from Lumen Health Software. Dana Reyes is a finalist for our Senior CSM role and gave consent for us to contact you. This takes about 20 minutes, and your answers stay with the hiring team only. Is now still a good time?"

2. Questions
#QuestionConcern testedStrong answer sounds likeRed-flag phrases
1Walk me through Dana's renewal results last year. What happened with accounts that didn't renew?Missed renewal targetNames accounts, causes, what she changed"Tough market," "not really her fault" with no detail
2Tell me about an account she saved from churn. What did she do herself?RenewalsSpecific actions and outcome"The team handled it," "I'd have to check"
3Describe a time she disagreed with a sales rep about a customer. How was it resolved?Friction with salesRaised it directly, agreed a plan"Strong opinions," "let's just say," long pause
4How did she pass expansion opportunities to sales?Friction with salesClear process, credited the rep"She liked to own it"
5What was the context when she left?14-month tenureClear and matches her account"Ask her," "it was mutual" with nothing more
6How did she prioritize a book of 40+ accounts?Account managementTiering, set cadence"She worked really hard" (effort, no method)
7What feedback did you give her most often, and what did she do with it?CoachabilitySpecific note, visible change"Nothing comes to mind"
8Would you hire her again for a similar role? What would you want in place?OverallQuick yes with concrete conditions"Probably," "in the right role"

Flagged: Your note that Dana "may need flexibility for her kids" relates to family status. Do not raise it.

3. Scoring sheet
Concern1234
RenewalsReference confirms repeated misses, no ownershipMisses explained vaguelyMisses explained, some fixesClear causes, fixes, and a save story
Sales collaborationOngoing conflict describedTension, unresolvedDisagreements resolvedSales sought her out
TenureStory conflicts with Dana'sUnclear reasonClear reason, consistentClear reason, would rehire
Overall rehireNoHesitantYes with conditionsImmediate yes
4. Decision rule

Average the four scores. 3.0+ proceed. 2.0-2.9 call a second reference, ideally a sales peer. Any single 1 pauses the offer until you discuss it with Dana.

References can describe past behavior but not how Dana will work with your sales team; test that with a joint call before the offer.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Tying each question to a named interview concern turns a polite chat into evidence on the exact risks you flagged.
  • Red-flag phrases per question help interviewers notice hedging, which references rarely state outright.
  • Asking the location first lets the model flag questions that are illegal or risky where you hire.

Use after final interviews, before the offer. Have your interview notes, the role's key skills and each reference's relationship to the candidate ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Ask for a 5-question version for a 10-minute call with a peer reference.
  • Add a column for interviewer notes and print the table as a call sheet.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in HR & Management