Write a Polite Candidate Rejection Email After an Interview in Three Tones

Get three rejection emails (short, warm, and with brief job-related feedback), each under 120 words, that avoid legally risky reasons and keep the decision clear.

Prompt

Prompt
You are an experienced HR manager who writes clear, respectful candidate communications.

Your job: write a rejection email for a candidate who interviewed but was not selected. Before writing, ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. What is the role title, the company name, and the candidate's first name?
2. How far did they get (phone screen, first interview, final round)?
3. What one or two real strengths did you notice, and what was the job-related reason they were not selected?
4. Should we invite them to apply again or keep them on file?

Rules:
- Write three versions: Short, Warm, and With Brief Feedback. Keep each under 120 words, including greeting and sign-off.
- State the decision clearly within the first two sentences. Do not add false hope.
- Never mention age, family, health, pregnancy, religion, nationality, accent, gender, disability, "culture fit" or any other personal trait. Base feedback only on the skills or experience I gave you.
- Do not invent strengths or reasons I did not give. If I gave none, keep the feedback general.
- Thank them for the specific time they spent, such as the final round.

Output format:
Subject line (one for all three)
Version 1 – Short
Version 2 – Warm
Version 3 – With Brief Feedback
Word count after each version.

End with one line flagging any wording to check with HR or legal. This is not legal advice. For employment law questions, ask an employment lawyer or a qualified HR professional.

Example output

At a glanceWord count of each rejection email versionAll three versions stay under the 120-word limit
  • Version 1 – Short: 56 words
  • Version 2 – Warm: 98 words
  • Version 3 – With Brief Feedback: 104 words

Example for: Priya, a final-round candidate for a Product Analyst role at Hollow Pine Software. She had a strong SQL case study but less A/B testing experience, and she will be kept on file.

Subject: Your application for Product Analyst at Hollow Pine Software

Version 1 – Short

Hi Priya,

Thank you for interviewing for the Product Analyst role at Hollow Pine Software. After careful consideration, we have decided not to move forward with your application.

We appreciate the time you gave us in the final round and wish you the best in your search.

Kind regards,
Dana Morales
Talent Partner, Hollow Pine Software

Word count: 56

Version 2 – Warm

Hi Priya,

Thank you for spending a full afternoon with our team in the final round for the Product Analyst role. This was a difficult decision, and we have chosen to move forward with another candidate.

We enjoyed getting to know you. We'd like to keep your details on file, and we'd be glad to hear from you if a role that fits your background opens up. Please feel free to apply again.

Thank you again for your interest in Hollow Pine Software. We wish you every success.

Warm regards,
Dana Morales
Talent Partner

Word count: 98

Version 3 – With Brief Feedback

Hi Priya,

Thank you for completing the final round for the Product Analyst role. We have decided to move forward with another candidate.

We wanted to share brief feedback. Your SQL case study was one of the strongest we saw, with clear queries and a well-structured walkthrough of your logic. The deciding factor was hands-on experience designing and analyzing A/B tests, which is a large part of this role in the first six months.

We'd welcome an application from you for future analyst openings, and we'll keep your details on file.

Best regards,
Dana Morales
Talent Partner, Hollow Pine Software

Word count: 104

Check: Version 3 names A/B testing as the deciding factor. Confirm it appears in the written job description, so the reason matches your documented requirements.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for the real, job-related reason first stops the model from guessing or inventing feedback.
  • An explicit list of banned topics keeps every version clear of discrimination-risky wording.
  • The 120-word cap and the rule to state the decision early keep emails short, kind and unambiguous.

Use this after a hiring decision, before you contact the candidate. Have the role, interview stage, real strengths, and the job-related reason ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Ask for a version for candidates who only had a phone screen, kept under 60 words.
  • Add your company's standard sign-off or a link to your careers page in every version.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in HR & Management