Build a Structured Interview Plan with Scored Questions for One Role

Get a structured interview plan that links every question to a competency, with a 1-4 rubric, weak and strong sample answers, and a weighted scorecard.

You getCompetency table, for each competency and scorecard

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an experienced talent acquisition lead who designs structured interviews.

Your job: build a structured interview plan for one role so that several interviewers score candidates the same way.

Before you start, ask me these questions in one message, then wait for my answers:
1. What is the role title, level and team?
2. What are the 3-5 things this person must do well in their first year?
3. How many interview rounds are there, and how long is each one?
4. What are the must-have skills or deal-breakers?

Rules:
- Name 4-6 competencies based on my answers, each with a one-line definition.
- Tie every question to exactly one competency. Use behavioral or situational questions only, with no trivia and no yes/no questions.
- Each 1-4 rubric level describes observable behavior, not adjectives like "good" or "strong."
- Give one short weak answer (score 1) and one strong answer (score 4) for each question.
- Leave out any question about age, family, health, religion, nationality or other protected traits. Remind me to check the questions with HR or against local employment law.

Output format:
1. Competency table: Competency | Definition | Weight (%) | Round
2. For each competency: the question, 2 follow-up probes, the 1-4 rubric, and the weak and strong example answers
3. Scorecard: how to total the weighted scores, and the hire/no-hire threshold
4. Interviewer instructions in 5 bullets

End by naming any competency you could not test well in the time available.

Example output

At a glanceCompetency weights in the CSM scorecardHire at a weighted 3.0 or above, with no competency scored 1
  • Account retention: 35%
  • Difficult conversations: 25%
  • Prioritization: 20%
  • Cross-team influence: 20%

Example for: a mid-level Customer Success Manager at a 60-person B2B software company, two 45-minute rounds.

1. Competencies
CompetencyDefinitionWeightRound
Account retentionSpots churn risk early and acts on it35%1
Difficult conversationsDelivers bad news clearly and keeps trust25%1
PrioritizationHandles 40+ accounts without dropping follow-ups20%2
Cross-team influenceGets product and support teams to act on customer needs20%2
2. Questions and Rubrics

Account retention
Q: Tell me about an account you thought you might lose. What did you notice, and what did you do?
Probes: Which signal came first? What was the result?

  • 1: Gives no specific account.
  • 2: Gives a real example, but only reacted after a complaint.
  • 3: Spotted a signal early and ran a plan.
  • 4: Did all of level 3, measured the result and changed the process afterward.

Weak: "I just keep customers happy." Strong: "Logins fell 40% after their admin left. I ran two trainings with the new admin, and they renewed at the same size."

Difficult conversations
Q: Describe a time you told a customer something they did not want to hear.
Probes: How did you prepare? How did they react?

  • 1: Avoided the conversation or handed it off.
  • 2: Delivered the news without offering options.
  • 3: Was clear and offered a next step.
  • 4: Did all of level 3 and kept or improved the relationship afterward.

Weak: "I let my manager handle it." Strong: "I told them the feature would slip a quarter, offered a workaround and set weekly check-ins. They stayed."

Prioritization
Q: You have 45 accounts, and 3 escalate on the same day. Walk me through your day.
Probes: What do you drop? Who do you tell?

  • 1: Says they would do everything.
  • 2: Picks an order but gives no reason.
  • 3: Ranks the accounts by revenue and risk.
  • 4: Does all of level 3, communicates the delays and blocks time to follow up.

Weak: "Work late." Strong: "Biggest renewal first, a 2-line update to the others, and a calendar block for each follow-up."

Cross-team influence
Q: Tell me about a customer request you got another team to act on.
Probes: What evidence did you bring? What happened?

  • 1: Just filed a ticket.
  • 2: Pushed the request, but it went nowhere.
  • 3: Built a case with customer data.
  • 4: Did all of level 3 and the request shipped or changed the roadmap.

Weak: "I logged it in Jira." Strong: "I grouped 12 accounts asking for SSO, worth $180k ARR. Product scheduled it the next quarter."

3. Scorecard

Weighted score = sum of (score x weight). The maximum is 4.0. Hire at 3.0 or above, and only if no competency scores 1.

4. Interviewer Instructions
  • Ask every question exactly as written.
  • Score alone before the debrief.
  • Write evidence notes for each score.
  • Use only the probes listed.
  • Do not discuss candidates until all scores are in.

Note: Cross-team influence is hard to test in 45 minutes, so consider adding a reference check. Confirm the questions with HR.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for the first-year goals first makes the competencies fit the real job, not a generic list.
  • Behavior-based 1-4 levels with weak and strong sample answers let different interviewers score the same way.
  • Weights and a hire threshold turn interview notes into a decision you can defend and compare.

Use this before opening a role or when interviewers keep disagreeing. Have the role level, first-year goals and round lengths ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Ask for a 30-minute phone screen version with only the two highest-weighted competencies.
  • Add a work-sample task with its own 1-4 rubric for technical roles.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in HR & Management