Turn Interview Notes into a Fair, Evidence-Based Hiring Recommendation

Paste your interview notes and get a hiring recommendation that separates evidence from impressions, rates each role criterion, and lists doubts to check before an offer.

You getRecommendation, criteria table and strengths

Prompt

Prompt
You are an experienced hiring manager and structured-interview coach. I will paste my interview notes for one candidate right after this message, plus the role's must-have criteria if I have them. If I don't include criteria, first ask me up to 3 short numbered questions about the role in one message and wait for my answers.

Your job: turn the notes into a fair hiring recommendation summary.

Rules:
1. Separate evidence (what the candidate said or did, quoted or closely paraphrased from the notes) from impressions (interviewer feelings such as "seemed confident"). Label each one.
2. Map every piece of evidence to one role criterion. Rate each criterion Strong, Mixed, Weak or No evidence, and never give a rating without citing the notes.
3. Flag and exclude any note about age, appearance, accent, family, health, nationality or other personal traits unrelated to the job.
4. Do not add facts, scores or details that are not in the notes.
5. Write open doubts as specific questions to check in a reference call or follow-up interview.

Output format:
- Recommendation: Hire / Lean hire / Lean no / No hire, with a one-sentence reason
- Criteria table: Criterion | Rating | Evidence from notes | Impressions only
- Strengths (max 3)
- Concerns (max 3)
- Flagged notes to exclude
- Open doubts to check before an offer

End with one line on what the notes are missing that limits confidence in this recommendation.

Example output

At a glancePriya R.: ratings and evidence by criterionRecommendation: Lean hire
ItemRatingEvidence from notes
Account retentionStrongChurn on 40 SMB accounts cut from 14% to 9%
Handling escalationsStrongCalled top 5 clients within 2 hours
Data useMixedHealth-score sheet; weights unexplained
Cross-team communicationMixedWeekly product sync; no outcome shown

Example for: notes on candidate "Priya R." for a Customer Success Manager role, criteria: account retention, handling escalations, data use, cross-team communication.

Recommendation: Lean hire. Strong, specific evidence on retention and escalations, but data skills rest on one example and need checking.

CriterionRatingEvidence from notesImpressions only
Account retentionStrong"Cut churn on my book of 40 SMB accounts from 14% to 9% in a year" by adding quarterly check-ins"Clearly cares about customers"
Handling escalationsStrongDescribed a billing outage: called the top 5 affected clients within 2 hours, got credits approved same day"Very calm"
Data useMixedBuilt a health-score spreadsheet; could not explain how weights were chosen"Maybe not technical"
Cross-team communicationMixedSays she ran a weekly sync with product; no example of an outcome from it"Good energy"

Strengths

  1. Measurable retention result with a clear method behind it.
  2. Fast, concrete action under pressure during an outage.
  3. Builds her own tools when none exist (health-score sheet).

Concerns

  1. Health-score logic was unclear when probed.
  2. No evidence that product sync changed anything.
  3. Only SMB experience; this role includes 6 mid-market accounts.

Flagged notes to exclude

  • "Has young kids, might need flexibility" (family status, not job-related).
  • "Strong accent on the phone" (accent, not job-related; communication is assessed on content above).

Open doubts to check before an offer

  1. Reference call: Did the churn drop hold after she left the accounts?
  2. Follow-up: Walk us through how you would rebuild the health score using our usage data.
  3. Reference call: Name one product change that came from her weekly sync.
  4. Follow-up: How would you adjust your approach for a 200-seat account with a procurement team?

Missing: no notes on the role-play exercise, and only one interviewer's view, so this rests on a single perspective.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Forcing a citation for every rating stops gut-feel scores from passing as evidence.
  • Splitting evidence and impressions in the table shows exactly where opinions are doing the work.
  • Flagging non-job-related notes reduces bias and legal risk before the debrief.

Use right after an interview while notes are fresh. Have your raw notes and the role's must-have criteria ready to paste into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Remove candidate surnames if your policy requires it.

Common edits

  • Paste notes from several interviewers and ask for a combined table showing where they disagree.
  • Swap the four-level recommendation for your company's own scorecard scale.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in HR & Management