Evaluate intern presentations for full-time conversion

Generate a fair rubric and debrief agenda to score final intern presentations and make return offer decisions.

You getEvaluation Rubric, 30-Minute Calibration Agenda and decision Criteria Matrix

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a university recruiting lead designing a return offer evaluation process.

Using the project summary and manager notes pasted below, build a conversion review guide.
- Establish a 4-part scoring rubric evaluating Execution, Communication, Problem Solving, and Culture & Collaboration.
- Create a 30-minute committee debrief agenda to calibrate final return offer decisions.
- Define clear signals that justify an immediate return offer, a follow-up interview, or a pass.

Output format:
- Evaluation Rubric (4 criteria, 1-4 scale with concrete behavioral anchors)
- 30-Minute Calibration Agenda
- Decision Criteria Matrix (Return Offer, Conditional/Second Look, Pass)

My notes are below:

Example output

Example for: an engineering intern presenting a refactored internal analytics dashboard

Evaluation Rubric
  1. Technical Execution
  • 1: Deliverable incomplete or broke existing workflows.
  • 2: Met minimal requirements; code needed heavy refactoring by mentors.
  • 3: Solid implementation; handled edge cases, followed clean code practices.
  • 4: Exceeded scope; optimized load times by 30% and authored clean tests.
  1. Communication & Presentation
  • 1: Could not clearly explain the business problem or architecture.
  • 2: Technical jargon without clear context for non-technical partners.
  • 3: Clear narrative connecting the project to team business goals.
  • 4: Compelling delivery; handled cross-functional Q&A with poise.
  1. Problem Solving & Independence
  • 1: Blocked easily without seeking help or trying solutions.
  • 2: Required step-by-step guidance on standard tasks.
  • 3: Researched alternatives before escalating blockers.
  • 4: Proactively identified security vulnerabilities and proposed fixes.
  1. Culture & Collaboration
  • 1: Worked in isolation; avoided peer feedback.
  • 2: Passive participant in team ceremonies.
  • 3: Sought feedback proactively; supported team members.
  • 4: Elevated team culture; documented findings for future hires.
30-Minute Calibration Agenda
  • 00-05 min: Review project scope and manager expectations
  • 05-15 min: Score presentation against rubric criteria
  • 15-25 min: Compare performance against peer benchmark
  • 25-30 min: Final vote and conversion determination
Decision Criteria Matrix
  • Return Offer: Average score 3.2+ with no score below 3; clear team willingness to rehire.
  • Conditional/Second Look: Score 2.7-3.1; strong potential but unconfirmed technical depth; requires one 45-minute technical follow-up.
  • Pass: Score below 2.7 or recurring performance/coachability concerns.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

In ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini, paste your intern project outline, manager notes, and presentation scope at the end. Follow up by asking for calibration questions to remove manager bias during final voting.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in HR & Management
HR & Management

Run a structured midpoint intern review

Run a clear 45-minute midpoint feedback conversation with an intern. Identifies key accomplishments, course corrections, and skill milestones before the final evaluation.

HR & Management

Create a peer intern buddy guide

Provide peer mentors with practical responsibilities, check-in checklists, and boundaries to support incoming interns.