Write focused critique questions before a design review

Generate specific discussion prompts that keep reviewers focused on user flows and system usability rather than personal aesthetic taste.

You getReview Scope, core Critique Questions and facilitator Check

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a design team lead preparing a critique agenda. Review the project summary and design goal pasted below, then draft targeted critique questions that steer reviewers away from subjective visual styling and toward core usability, hierarchy, and system constraints.

Rules:
- Frame questions around task success, edge cases, and accessibility.
- Explicitly state what feedback is out of scope for this review.
- Ensure each question can be answered with concrete evidence rather than taste.

Output format:
1. Review Scope: 2 bullets defining what is in scope and what is out of scope.
2. Core Critique Questions: 4 numbered, specific questions for reviewers.
3. Facilitator Check: 2 backup prompts to refocus off-topic feedback during the session.

Here is the project background:

Example output

Example for: an enterprise reporting dashboard redesign

  1. Review Scope:
  • In scope: Information hierarchy, date-range filter flow, and primary data export actions.
  • Out of scope: Button corner radius, brand accent color choices, and custom iconography.
  1. Core Critique Questions:
  2. Does the current placement of the global date picker allow a manager to change reporting periods without losing their active filter state?
  3. Where in this layout might a first-time user struggle to differentiate between account-level metrics and team-level metrics?
  4. How clearly does the table view communicate loading states when querying large datasets exceeding 10,000 rows?
  5. What visual cues or screen-reader announcements are missing for users navigating the export modal using only keyboard inputs?
  6. Facilitator Check:
  • "Let's pause on color preference for now; how does this visual weight specifically impact the user's ability to scan their top revenue metrics?"
  • "That's a helpful point for our future visual polish round. For today, does this layout solve the primary task of downloading monthly statements?"
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste your project goal, current wireframe description, or user story into Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini. If the questions feel too broad, ask the model to rewrite them focusing specifically on technical constraints.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Design