Structured Design Critique and Feedback Framework
Get an objective, structured critique of your UI design that highlights specific observations, technical trade-offs, and actionable priority revisions.
Prompt
Act as a Senior Product Designer. I will provide a link to a design or a detailed description of a screen. Your job is to conduct a professional design critique using a formal framework. Follow these rules: 1. Keep all feedback objective and grounded in established UX principles like Jakob Nielsen's heuristics. 2. For every issue identified, explicitly state the trade-off between user experience, engineering effort, and business goals. 3. Categorize all suggested revisions by priority: Critical, High, or Low. 4. Avoid vague praise or subjective opinions. First, ask me these 3 questions: 1. What is the primary user goal of this screen? 2. Who is the target audience for this interface? 3. Are there any specific technical or brand constraints I should know about? Wait for my answers before providing the critique. Output format: # Design Critique Summary. ## Observations: Bulleted list of specific UI/UX issues. ## Trade-off Analysis: A table with columns Issue, UX Impact, and Engineering Effort. ## Prioritized Revisions: A numbered list of fixes categorized by impact. This is not professional consulting; please consult a senior product manager for final sign-off.Example output
Tips and common edits
Why this works
- Forces objective analysis by requiring explicit trade-offs for every issue.
- Categorizes feedback to help you decide what to fix first vs later.
- Uses a structured framework to prevent subjective or emotional feedback loops.
Use this prompt when you have a wireframe, high-fidelity mockup, or live interface that needs a sanity check. Works best in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. Paste your design description or share a screenshot after answering the initial questions.
Common edits
- Add specific accessibility standards like WCAG 2.1 to the prompt constraints.
- Change the output format to include a section for specific CSS or code implementation hints.
Make it repeatable
Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.
Prompt details
- By
- Prompts-GPT editors
- Published
Did this prompt work?
Keep exploring
More like this
Triage conflicting design feedback by user impact
Turn contradictory stakeholder notes into an objective tradeoff matrix with clear decisions. Use it when design reviews stall over opposing priorities.
Write focused critique questions before a design review
Generate specific discussion prompts that keep reviewers focused on user flows and system usability rather than personal aesthetic taste.
Translate vague design feedback into actionable visual revisions
Convert unhelpful client comments like 'make it pop' into precise visual design adjustments, CSS values, and client questions.
Audit and Rewrite UX Error Messages for User Recovery
Get actionable, plain-language rewrites for your software error messages based on a four-part usability rubric to improve user recovery rates.
Design a Progressive Disclosure Pattern for Complex Settings
Receive a structured layout strategy for grouping advanced software settings into primary and hidden tiers to reduce user cognitive load and interface clutter.
Turn user interview quotes into an empathy map
Synthesize raw interview quotes into a standard four-quadrant empathy map with actionable pains and gains. Ideal for UX designers debriefing qualitative research.
- Build an SVG Line Icon Set Preview Sheet with Size and Stroke Controls
- Check UI microcopy for text expansion risks
- Brainstorm product and feature names with positioning rationale
- Plan a wireframe content hierarchy before sketching
- Write clear microcopy for confirmations and destructive actions
- Frontend Design Direction Brief So Your Coding Agent Avoids the Generic AI Look