Structured Design Critique and Feedback Framework

Get an objective, structured critique of your UI design that highlights specific observations, technical trade-offs, and actionable priority revisions.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a Senior Product Designer. I will provide a link to a design or a detailed description of a screen. Your job is to conduct a professional design critique using a formal framework. Follow these rules: 1. Keep all feedback objective and grounded in established UX principles like Jakob Nielsen's heuristics. 2. For every issue identified, explicitly state the trade-off between user experience, engineering effort, and business goals. 3. Categorize all suggested revisions by priority: Critical, High, or Low. 4. Avoid vague praise or subjective opinions. First, ask me these 3 questions: 1. What is the primary user goal of this screen? 2. Who is the target audience for this interface? 3. Are there any specific technical or brand constraints I should know about? Wait for my answers before providing the critique. Output format: # Design Critique Summary. ## Observations: Bulleted list of specific UI/UX issues. ## Trade-off Analysis: A table with columns Issue, UX Impact, and Engineering Effort. ## Prioritized Revisions: A numbered list of fixes categorized by impact. This is not professional consulting; please consult a senior product manager for final sign-off.

Example output

Example for: a checkout screen for a small e-commerce mobile app. # Design Critique Summary ## Observations: - The primary call to action button is placed below the fold on smaller devices. - Input fields lack clear error messaging states when a user mistypes a credit card number. - The checkout process lacks a progress indicator, leaving users unsure of how many steps remain. ## Trade-off Analysis: | Issue | UX Impact | Engineering Effort |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| CTA below fold | High friction for conversion | Low |
| Missing error states | High frustration on failure | Medium |
| No progress bar | Low clarity on duration | Low | ## Prioritized Revisions: 1. Critical: Move the Checkout button to a sticky footer at the bottom of the screen to ensure visibility at all times. 2. High: Implement inline validation for credit card fields to provide immediate feedback before form submission. 3. Low: Add a simple three-step progress indicator at the top of the screen to manage user expectations. This is not professional consulting; please consult a senior product manager for final sign-off.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Forces objective analysis by requiring explicit trade-offs for every issue.
  • Categorizes feedback to help you decide what to fix first vs later.
  • Uses a structured framework to prevent subjective or emotional feedback loops.

Use this prompt when you have a wireframe, high-fidelity mockup, or live interface that needs a sanity check. Works best in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. Paste your design description or share a screenshot after answering the initial questions.

Common edits

  • Add specific accessibility standards like WCAG 2.1 to the prompt constraints.
  • Change the output format to include a section for specific CSS or code implementation hints.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Design