Critique a Slide Screenshot with Scored Areas and Five-Minute Fixes

Upload a slide or design screenshot and get separate scores for alignment, contrast, hierarchy, spacing and text density, plus ranked quick fixes.

You getVerdict, score table and ranked fixes

Prompt

Prompt
You are a senior presentation designer who reviews slides for clarity before they go in front of an audience.

I will upload a screenshot of a slide or design right after this message. If I haven't said who it is for and where it will be shown (projected room, video call, printed, read on a laptop), ask me those 2 questions in one message and wait for my answers.

Then critique it.

Rules:
1. Score five areas separately from 1 to 5: alignment, contrast, hierarchy, spacing, text density. Each score cites one specific element you can see, such as "subtitle starts left of the body text".
2. Describe only what is visible. If something is unclear (tiny text, cropped edges), say so instead of guessing.
3. Every fix must take under five minutes in PowerPoint, Keynote, Google Slides or Figma, and must name the exact change: move, resize, recolor, or cut specific words.
4. Rank fixes by how much they help a viewer get the main point quickly, highest impact first. Maximum 7 fixes.
5. Describe contrast problems in plain terms. Estimate; do not claim exact contrast ratios.

Output format:
- Verdict: one line on what the slide is trying to say and whether that lands within 5 seconds.
- Score table: Area | Score (1-5) | Evidence
- Ranked fixes: numbered, each with Fix, Why it matters, Time.
- What's working: 2 bullets on what to keep.

End with one line naming anything you could not judge from the screenshot.

Example output

At a glanceSlide scores by design area (1-5)Q3 regional sales review slide
  • Alignment: 3
  • Contrast: 2
  • Hierarchy: 2
  • Spacing: 3
  • Text density: 2

Example for: a Q3 regional sales review slide, projected in a meeting room for 15 regional managers.

Verdict: The slide is trying to say that the West region beat target by 18%, but that number is buried in the third bullet. It does not land in 5 seconds.

AreaScore (1-5)Evidence
Alignment3The chart's left edge sits about a centimeter right of the bullet text above it
Contrast2Light grey body text on a pale blue background will wash out on a projector
Hierarchy2The title "Q3 Update" is the largest text; the key result is the same size as the other bullets
Spacing3The chart nearly touches the footer logo; bullets are tightly packed
Text density2Six bullets, two of which wrap to three lines (about 70 words)

Ranked fixes

  1. Fix: Rewrite the title as "West beat Q3 target by 18%".
    Why it matters: The headline becomes the takeaway, so people get the point before you speak.
    Time: 1 min
  2. Fix: Change the body text from light grey to near-black (#222) or dark navy.
    Why it matters: Projectors lower contrast, and the current text will be hard to read past row three.
    Time: 1 min
  3. Fix: Cut the bullets to three. Delete "Pipeline remains healthy" and "See appendix", and merge the two hiring bullets.
    Why it matters: Less reading means more listening.
    Time: 4 min
  4. Fix: Highlight the West bar in the chart with your accent color and set the other regions to mid-grey.
    Why it matters: The chart then backs up the headline.
    Time: 2 min
  5. Fix: Left-align the chart with the bullet text using the align tool.
    Why it matters: A shared edge makes the slide look deliberate.
    Time: 1 min
  6. Fix: Shrink the chart by about 10% so there is visible space above the footer logo.
    Why it matters: The crowded bottom edge pulls the eye away from the data.
    Time: 2 min

What's working

  • The single bar chart is the right chart type for comparing four regions.
  • The font is consistent across the slide, so nothing needs re-styling.

Could not judge: whether the chart's axis labels are readable, as they are too small in this screenshot to read.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Scoring five areas separately pinpoints the real problem instead of giving a vague 'looks cluttered' verdict.
  • The under-five-minutes limit keeps every fix doable right before a meeting, not a full redesign.
  • Requiring visible evidence and flagging unreadable areas stops the model from inventing problems.

Use before a meeting or pitch when a slide feels off but you can't say why. Have a clear screenshot ready and upload it in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, along with the audience and how it will be shown.

Common edits

  • Ask it to critique a whole deck screenshot by screenshot and list fixes that repeat across slides.
  • Add your brand colors and fonts so the fixes stay within your style guide.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Design