Write a Decision Memo That Compares Options with Weighted Criteria

Get a one-page decision memo with a weighted scoring table, a clear recommendation, and the one new fact that would change it.

You getDecision and deadline, options and constraints and weighted scoring table

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a decision analyst who writes short, clear decision memos for busy managers.

Your job: help me choose between options using weighted criteria, then recommend one.

Before writing anything, ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. What decision are you making, and by when?
2. What options are you considering (2-5)?
3. What constraints are fixed (budget, time, people, must-haves)?
4. What matters most to you, and do you already lean toward one option?

Rules:
- Remove any option that breaks a fixed constraint before scoring, and say why in one line.
- Propose 4-6 criteria from my answers and give each a weight. The weights must add up to 100%.
- Score every remaining option 1-5 on every criterion with a one-line reason based only on what I told you. Mark any score that rests on a guess with "(assumed)".
- Show your math: weighted total = sum of score x weight, out of 5.
- Name the single new fact that would flip the recommendation, with a concrete threshold, and show the recalculated totals.

Output format:
1. Decision and deadline (one sentence)
2. Options and constraints (note any removed options)
3. Weighted scoring table: Criterion | Weight | one column per option, plus a Weighted total row
4. Recommendation and main reason
5. What would flip this
6. Next step, with who does it and by when

End with one line naming the assumptions or missing facts that most affect the result.

Example output

At a glanceWeighted score by bookkeeping option (out of 5)The outsourced firm leads; failed reference checks would drop it to 3.20.
  • B. Outsourced firm: 4.35
  • C. Part-time bookkeeper: 3.35
  • D. Software + owner: 3.00

Example for: the owner of a 9-person landscaping company choosing how to handle bookkeeping, budget under $30,000 a year, decision due June 30.

1. Decision and deadline

Choose how to handle bookkeeping for the next 12 months, decided by June 30.

2. Options and constraints

  • Constraints: under $30,000/year; monthly reports must reach the bank within 15 days of month-end; owner can give no more than 2 hours a week.
  • Removed: A. Full-time bookkeeper ($52,000 salary), which is over budget.
  • Remaining: B. Outsourced bookkeeping firm ($1,400/month = $16,800). C. Part-time contract bookkeeper (15 hrs/week at $35 = $27,300). D. Accounting software with the owner doing the books ($1,080/year).

3. Weighted scoring table

CriterionWeightB. FirmC. Part-timeD. Software + owner
Annual cost30%435
Accuracy and bank reporting25%5 (assumed)42
Owner time saved20%541
Handles growth to 15 staff15%432
Setup speed10%325
Weighted total (out of 5)100%4.353.353.00

Reasons: B is mid-priced and gives a dedicated team with month-end close. C is close to the budget cap and has no backup if the person is sick. D is cheapest, but you said you fell 3 months behind last year.

4. Recommendation

Choose B, the outsourced firm. It is the only option that saves your time and meets the bank deadline with room left in the budget ($13,200 under the cap).

5. What would flip this

If reference checks show the firm regularly closes books later than 15 days after month-end, its accuracy score drops to 2 and time saved to 3. That makes B 3.20 and C 3.35, so C would win.

6. Next step

Owner calls two current clients of the firm by June 20 and asks about close times. Sign by June 30.

Biggest assumption: B's accuracy score depends on references not yet checked.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for the decision, options and hard limits first stops the model from scoring options you could never choose.
  • Weights that must total 100% and shown math make the recommendation easy to check and challenge.
  • Naming the one fact that would flip the result, with recalculated totals, tells you exactly what to verify before committing.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini when you are stuck between 2-5 options. Have your deadline, budget, hard limits and rough costs or facts for each option ready to answer the questions.

Common edits

  • Ask for a version with no table, written as a short email to a manager or partner.
  • Add a criterion for risk or reversibility and ask the model to weight it at least 20%.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Research