Triage peer review reports into an actionable revision plan

Break down messy journal referee reports into structured categories based on effort, impact, and co-author responsibilities.

You getTriage summary table with columns, direct conflicts between reviewers and proposed resolutions and immediate first-week priorities list

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an academic publishing coordinator. Organize and triage the provided peer review comments into an efficient, actionable revision roadmap.
- Break multi-part reviewer remarks into discrete, standalone action items.
- Assign each item to one of three categories: Major (requires new experiments or substantial re-analysis), Moderate (requires rewriting, re-plotting, or supplemental clarifications), or Minor (typos, citation updates, and formatting tweaks).
- Flag conflicting advice between reviewers and propose a unified compromise.
- Note which co-author role (lead author, statistician, lab lead) should handle each task.
Output format:
1. Triage summary table with columns: ID, Reviewer & Comment #, Category, Action Required, Assigned Role, Estimated Effort (Low/Med/High)
2. Direct conflicts between reviewers and proposed resolutions
3. Immediate first-week priorities list

Here are the reviewer comments:

Example output

Example for: two reviewer reports on a clinical survey study with conflicting advice on sample exclusion

1. Triage Summary Table

| ID | Reviewer & Comment # | Category | Action Required | Assigned Role | Estimated Effort |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| 1 | Rev 1, Point 1 | Major | Re-run primary regression model controlling for patient age clusters | Statistician | High |
| 2 | Rev 1, Point 2 | Minor | Correct citation year for Miller et al. and fix label on Figure 3 | Lead Author | Low |
| 3 | Rev 2, Point 1 | Moderate | Rewrite Section 4.2 to clarify why non-responders were excluded from Wave 2 | Lead Author | Med |
| 4 | Rev 2, Point 2 | Major | Conduct sensitivity analysis including previously excluded borderline cases | Statistician | High |
| 5 | Rev 2, Point 3 | Minor | Expand abbreviations list in Table 1 footnotes | Co-author / RA | Low |

2. Reviewer Conflicts and Proposed Resolutions

Conflict: Reviewer 1 requests dropping incomplete cohort records entirely to preserve data purity, whereas Reviewer 2 insists on retaining incomplete records via multiple imputation to avoid attrition bias.

Proposed Resolution: Keep the primary complete-case analysis in the main text as requested by Reviewer 1, but run multiple imputation as a supplementary sensitivity analysis (Supplementary Table S2) to satisfy Reviewer 2, demonstrating that the main statistical conclusions remain robust under both treatments.

3. Immediate First-Week Priorities
  1. Statistician pulls raw survey data to script the sensitivity re-analysis (Tasks 1 and 4).
  2. Lead author drafts the Section 4.2 text explanation on sample inclusion rationale.
  3. Research assistant resolves minor citation and table footnote edits.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Copy and paste the full text of all reviewer reports directly after the prompt in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. If your team has specific roles or lab constraints, ask the model in a follow-up message to redistribute the workload around those constraints.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Academic Writing & Study
Academic Writing & Study

Write constructive peer feedback on a draft

Draft specific, respectful, and rubric-aligned peer review comments for a student paper. Use this to provide actionable revision notes without taking over the author's voice.