Convert blunt advisor comments into a prioritized revision plan

Translates cryptic, critical margin notes from thesis advisors into actionable revision tasks sorted by urgency and scope.

You getSummary Diagnosis, priority 1 and priority 2

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an experienced graduate advisor and academic editor. Translate the pasted blunt professor comments and draft excerpts into a constructive, prioritized revision checklist.

- Decode ambiguous, brief, or harsh margin notes (e.g., 'so what?', 'cite?', 'unclear', 'redundant') into specific scholarly shortcomings.
- Group tasks into conceptual structural issues, argument gaps, and prose-level polish.
- Flag which items require advisor re-approval versus self-directed fixes.

Output format:
- Summary Diagnosis (2 sentences on the advisor's core concern)
- Priority 1: Structural & Argument Adjustments (table with columns: Comment, Underlying Issue, Actionable Revision Step, Needs Advisor Sign-off?)
- Priority 2: Evidence & Citation Gaps (numbered list with specific fixes)
- Priority 3: Clarity & Style Polish (bulleted list)

Here are the comments and draft context:

Example output

Example for: dissertation chapter feedback on a qualitative sociolinguistics study

Summary Diagnosis

Your advisor finds the theoretical foundation sound but believes the qualitative findings section lacks interpretive depth. The draft currently reads like a descriptive summary of interview quotes rather than an analytical synthesis that challenges current literature.

Priority 1: Structural & Argument Adjustments
CommentUnderlying IssueActionable Revision StepNeeds Advisor Sign-off?
'So what? We know this already.'The participant quote merely confirms baseline assumptions without advancing your thesis.Frame this section around the single unexpected conversational shift found in transcript 4; explain how it refines Bourdieu's concept of linguistic capital.Yes
'Where is the mechanism?'The transition between language socialization and code-switching choice is asserted rather than demonstrated.Add a transitional subsection detailing the cognitive and social constraints participants reported during formal office hours.Yes
'Cut the throat-clearing.'Two opening pages summarize textbook history rather than engaging directly with your field site data.Delete pages 42-43; move the single essential historical definition to a footnote on page 44.No
Priority 2: Evidence & Citation Gaps
  1. Add empirical support on page 48: The claim that second-generation speakers resist peer-group shifts requires two recent post-2020 ethnographic citations.
  2. Reconcile contradictory claims on page 51: You state code-meshing is 'increasingly normalized' but cited a 2012 study noting high professional penalties; add clarification on domain differences (informal vs. formal workplace contexts).
Priority 3: Clarity & Style Polish
  • Replace recurring passive constructions in Section 3.2 ('It was observed that...') with active analytical verbs ('Participants signaled...').
  • Standardize terminology between 'code-switching' and 'translanguaging' across the entire chapter.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste your professor's raw feedback along with the relevant draft sentences into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. Follow up by asking the model to draft a professional email reply explaining how you plan to address the priority items.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Academic Writing & Study
Academic Writing & Study

Write constructive peer feedback on a draft

Draft specific, respectful, and rubric-aligned peer review comments for a student paper. Use this to provide actionable revision notes without taking over the author's voice.