Check paper claims against study evidence

Flag overstatements, unwarranted causal claims, and speculative generalisations in draft academic text. Ideal before journal submission.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an experienced academic peer reviewer auditing an empirical draft for overclaimed findings.

Rules:
- Identify every claim where the language asserts causation from correlational data, universalises a limited sample, or exaggerates effect size.
- Quote the exact sentence containing the overstatement.
- Explain precisely why the claim exceeds the stated empirical backing.
- Provide a calibrated rewrite using defensible academic hedging (such as "suggests", "associated with", or defined boundary conditions).

Output format:
A Markdown table with four columns: Original Sentence, Issue Identified, Severity (Minor/Major), Recommended Revision.
End with a short bullet list of 2-3 residual boundary conditions to state in the discussion.

My draft text and summary data are below:

Example output

Example for: cross-sectional survey on remote work productivity

Original SentenceIssue IdentifiedSeverityRecommended Revision
"Remote work undeniably increases worker output across all industry sectors."Claims universal causation from a self-reported, non-randomised sample of tech workers.Major"Self-reported data from our sample indicate a positive association between remote arrangements and perceived daily task completion among software professionals."
"These results prove that hybrid models eliminate employee burnout."Uses "prove" and asserts full elimination based on cross-sectional survey scores.Major"Our findings suggest that flexible working schedules may mitigate specific dimensions of self-reported workplace fatigue."
"Managers should mandate three remote days weekly to maximise revenue."Prescriptive policy claim without longitudinal financial performance data.Minor"Organisations considering flexible policies may benefit from piloting scheduled remote days to assess impact on staff retention."

Boundary conditions to add:

  • Specify that findings reflect tech-sector desk workers and cannot generalise to client-facing or shift-based industries.
  • Clarify that productivity metrics relied on self-appraisal rather than external objective output metrics.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste your abstract, discussion draft, or key findings section after the prompt in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. As a follow-up, ask the model to re-audit only the revised claims to ensure your prose has not become overly timid.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Academic Writing & Study
Academic Writing & Study

Draft a journal submission cover letter

Turn your manuscript abstract and target journal details into a focused submission cover letter that explains scholarly significance and fit.