Build a pre-submission reproducibility audit checklist

Generate a comprehensive methodological checklist to verify code, data availability, blinding, and statistical parameters before journal submission.

You getCore methodology checklist grouped by domain, high-risk desk rejection triggers list and pre-flight sign-off box template

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an academic journal methods editor. Create a pre-submission reproducibility audit checklist that researchers can use to verify their manuscript before submitting to a peer-reviewed journal.
- Cover essential criteria across study design, sample size justification, participant/subject allocation, code availability, data sharing, and statistical reporting.
- Detail specific verification items for data repositories, random seeds, reagent identifiers, inclusion/exclusion criteria, and ethics statements.
- Ensure the checklist applies across both quantitative empirical research and computational modeling.
- Include clear pass/fail verification points that reviewers and editors evaluate during initial desk triage.
Output format:
1. Core methodology checklist grouped by domain: Study Design & Sampling, Materials & Instruments, Data & Code Transparency, and Statistical Reporting
2. High-risk desk rejection triggers list
3. Pre-flight sign-off box template

Example output

1. Core Methodology Reproducibility Checklist

Study Design & Sampling

  • [ ] Power Calculation: Explicit a priori sample size determination provided with effect size, alpha, and power parameters stated.
  • [ ] Allocation Rules: Detailed description of randomization procedures, blinding protocols, and sham/control assignments.
  • [ ] Attrition Details: Full accounting of dropouts, excluded outliers, and missing data points, including explicit pre-established exclusion criteria.

Materials, Reagents & Instruments

  • [ ] Unique Identifiers: Research Resource Identifiers (RRIDs), vendor names, and catalog numbers listed for antibodies, cell lines, and specialized equipment.
  • [ ] Authentication: Cell line mycoplasma testing and genetic authentication methods documented.
  • [ ] Operating Conditions: Physical settings (temperature, flow rates, software versions, firmware) completely recorded.

Data & Code Transparency

  • [ ] Repository Deposit: Raw, anonymized data deposited in a citable repository (e.g., Zenodo, OSF, Dryad) with an active DOI.
  • [ ] Execution Pipeline: Clean scripts, README file, environment dependency specifications, and fixed random seeds included.
  • [ ] Licensing: Data and code access licenses clearly declared.

Statistical Reporting

  • [ ] Exact Metrics: Exact p-values reported (e.g., p = 0.031 rather than p < 0.05), alongside degrees of freedom and test statistics.
  • [ ] Dispersion Definitions: Error bars explicitly defined in every figure legend (e.g., SD vs. SEM vs. 95% CI).
  • [ ] Multi-Testing Corrections: Corrections for multiple testing (e.g., Bonferroni, FDR) explicitly documented where applicable.
2. High-Risk Desk Rejection Triggers
  • Statement reads "Data available upon reasonable request" without valid ethical or legal restrictions.
  • Missing institutional review board (IRB) or animal ethics committee approval numbers.
  • Figures lack sample size (n) counts in corresponding legends.
3. Pre-Flight Sign-Off Box

Lead Author Verification

  • Manuscript Title:
  • Primary Repository DOI:
  • Code Repository URL / Tag:
  • I confirm that raw data, analysis scripts, and experimental logs have been cross-checked for reproducibility.
  • Signature / Date:
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste this prompt directly into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini without modifications. Once generated, run through each checklist item with your co-authors during your final internal review meeting before upload.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Academic Writing & Study
Academic Writing & Study

Draft a journal submission cover letter

Turn your manuscript abstract and target journal details into a focused submission cover letter that explains scholarly significance and fit.

Academic Writing & Study

Check paper claims against study evidence

Flag overstatements, unwarranted causal claims, and speculative generalisations in draft academic text. Ideal before journal submission.