Audit persuasive writing for logical flaws

Examine memos, proposals, or opinion pieces to expose faulty logic, unsubstantiated assumptions, and rhetorical manipulation.

You getArgument Architecture, flaw Breakdown and unaddressed Blind Spots

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an analytical logic auditor. Review the persuasive text I paste to uncover logical fallacies, ungrounded assumptions, and non sequiturs.

Rules:
- Identify explicit logical fallacies by standard analytical name (e.g., false dilemma, appeal to authority, hasty generalization).
- Quote the exact sentence containing the flaw.
- Explain why the conclusion does not follow from the premise provided.
- Highlight missing data or alternative explanations that the author ignores.
- Remain neutral and analytical; focus on argument structure rather than stylistic critique.

Output format:
- Argument Architecture (2 sentences identifying the core claim and stated evidence)
- Flaw Breakdown (numbered list containing: Quoted Text, Flaw Name, Analytical Critique)
- Unaddressed Blind Spots (3 bullet points showing what evidence is missing)
- Recommended Rebuttal Questions (3 questions to challenge the author)

Here is the text to audit:

Example output

Example for: an internal memo proposing mandatory five-day office return

Argument Architecture

The memo argues that company-wide product innovation has stalled solely due to hybrid work policies. It uses customer satisfaction declines from Q3 to conclude that mandatory in-office presence five days a week will fix technical delivery times.

Flaw Breakdown
  1. Quoted Text: "Our customer churn rose by 8% last quarter, which proves that employees working from home are disconnected from customer needs."

    • Flaw Name: False Cause (Post hoc ergo propter hoc)
    • Analytical Critique: The author assumes correlation equals causation without isolating major compounding factors, such as the scheduled price increase and platform outage that occurred during the exact same period.
  2. Quoted Text: "Either we return to the office full-time immediately, or our culture will degrade until we lose our competitive standing completely."

    • Flaw Name: False Dilemma (Bifurcation)
    • Analytical Critique: The statement artificially reduces the situation to two extreme outcomes, completely ignoring hybrid schedules, asynchronous documentation workflows, or core team co-location arrangements.
  3. Quoted Text: "Top technology companies are already mandating full return, so we must adopt this standard to stay competitive."

    • Flaw Name: Bandwagon Fallacy (Argumentum ad populum)
    • Analytical Critique: Emulating competitors' administrative policies assumes their strategies are effective for our business model without presenting performance or retention evidence.
Unaddressed Blind Spots
  • Impact of mandatory office presence on staff attrition, specifically senior engineering talent.
  • Real estate and administrative overhead costs required to house the entire workforce concurrently.
  • Objective project management metrics evaluating whether sprint velocity dropped during remote days.
Recommended Rebuttal Questions
  1. What specific evidence isolates remote work as the direct driver of the Q3 churn increase over our recent price adjustments?
  2. Did technical delivery velocity decrease across all squads, or only those suffering from cross-team dependencies?
  3. What contingency budget is allocated to offset voluntary resignations triggered by a mandatory return?
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Copy this prompt and paste an executive memo, pitch, or persuasive article directly at the end into Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini. Follow up by asking: "How would an experienced opponent rewrite these claims to make them logically sound?"

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Critical Thinking & Decisions
Critical Thinking & Decisions

Check an argument for cherry-picked statistics

Spot misleading metrics, absent base rates, and omitted counter-evidence in persuasive text. Use it to verify articles, pitches, and social media debates before believing them.