Identify perverse incentives in a proposed policy

Expose unintended consequences, metric gaming, and perverse incentives hidden inside proposed rules. Perfect for managers drafting new KPIs or policies.

You getPrimary Vulnerabilities, unintended Casualties and countermeasures

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a systems thinker and behavioral economist. Analyze the policy draft pasted below to uncover hidden perverse incentives, metric gaming, and unintended behavioral side effects.
- Map out 3 distinct ways rational actors will exploit or game the rules to meet targets while hurting overall value.
- Identify who bears the hidden operational cost or burden when this policy is enforced.
- Provide concrete revisions or counter-metrics to neutralize these loopholes without adding bureaucracy.
Output format:
1. Primary Vulnerabilities (how people will game this)
2. Unintended Casualties (teams or metrics harmed)
3. Countermeasures (revised rules or pairing metrics)

My policy draft is below:

Example output

Example for: proposal to tie customer support bonuses strictly to tickets closed per hour

  1. Primary Vulnerabilities
  • Cherry-Picking Easy Tickets: Agents will selectively claim password resets and canned inquiries while abandoning complex, multi-day technical bugs.
  • Premature Resolution: Agents will mark tickets resolved after sending a generic brush-off response, forcing clients to reopen new tickets and artificially inflating volume.
  • Decreased Collaboration: Experienced reps will stop mentoring junior staff or updating internal documentation because time spent helping others lowers their personal ticket rate.
  1. Unintended Casualties
  • Customer Retention: Complex enterprise customers face longer waits and sloppy service, directly driving churn.
  • Tier 2 Engineering: Unresolved issues get dumped indiscriminately upstream to escalate tickets off the support queue.
  1. Countermeasures
  • Pair Metrics: Tie the speed target directly to a minimum 90% Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) floor and a 48-hour reopen rate below 5%.
  • Random Quality Sampling: Audit 5 random tickets per rep weekly for resolution accuracy; failing the audit forfeits the volume bonus.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste your proposed policy or KPI rules after the prompt in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. As a follow-up, ask the model to draft an edge-case test scenario with specific worker personas.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Critical Thinking & Decisions
Critical Thinking & Decisions

Stress test an optimistic project timeline

Expose hidden friction, coordination overhead, and missing buffers in your project schedule. Use it before committing to deadlines with clients or executive leadership.

Critical Thinking & Decisions

Stress test a strong gut feeling

Pressure-test an instinctive business decision against hidden assumptions and worst-case realities. Use it before signing a contract or greenlighting spend.