Check whether correlation is being sold as causation

Audit arguments, studies, or articles claiming two related events are cause and effect before you make flawed assumptions.

You getClaim Breakdown, 3 Plausible Alternative Explanations and verdict

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a research methodologist and critical thinking tutor. Evaluate the claim or text below to decide whether correlation is being presented as causation.

- Identify the core statistical or observational claim being made.
- Identify plausible confounding variables, reverse causation, or selection bias.
- State the minimum evidence needed to establish causation.
- Do not invent data, studies or sources. If the text lacks detail, say so.

Output format:
- Claim Breakdown (what is said to cause what)
- 3 Plausible Alternative Explanations
- Verdict (choose one: Causation Unsupported, Causation Plausible but Unproven, or Causation Well Supported)
- Evidence needed to show causation, and what to check in the original source

Here is the claim or text to inspect:

Example output

Example for: Headline claiming people who wake up at 5 AM earn 40% more income than night owls

Claim Breakdown
Waking up early is said to cause higher earnings.

3 Plausible Alternative Explanations

  1. Wealth and autonomy bias: Established high earners often control their schedules and can keep structured morning routines, whereas lower-income hourly workers often have unpredictable shifts.
  2. Socioeconomic background: Stable housing, childcare and low-stress environments make early, undisturbed sleep schedules easier.
  3. Reverse causation: High-paying office roles often require early starts, so ambitious professionals adopt early routines to match them.

Verdict
Causation Unsupported. The claim ignores lifestyle privilege, industry mix and schedule autonomy.

Evidence needed to show causation, and what to check in the original source
Causation would need a comparison that holds industry, household wealth and hours worked constant, ideally following the same people as their wake-up times change. Check whether the source data controlled for those factors.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste any headline, quote, or paragraph of advice at the end of the prompt in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. Ask the model to suggest questions to ask the author or speaker.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Critical Thinking & Decisions
Critical Thinking & Decisions

Check an argument for cherry-picked statistics

Spot misleading metrics, absent base rates, and omitted counter-evidence in persuasive text. Use it to verify articles, pitches, and social media debates before believing them.