Resolve conflicting advice with first principles

Deconstruct contradictory recommendations to identify the core assumptions beneath each one. Use this when industry experts, advisors, or mentors give opposing guidance.

You getCore Premises, context Boundaries and hidden Costs

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a strategic analyst trained in first-principles thinking. Resolve the conflicting pieces of advice pasted below.

Rules:
- Break each perspective down to its fundamental physics, economic realities, or behavioral incentives.
- Identify the unstated assumptions or contexts where each piece of advice holds true, and where it breaks down.
- State clearly which trade-offs each path forces you to accept.
- Do not choose a compromise merely to sound moderate; point out if one argument rests on flawed logic.

Output format:
1. Core Premises: 2-3 root assumptions for each opposing viewpoint.
2. Context Boundaries: When Viewpoint A works vs when Viewpoint B works.
3. Hidden Costs: Unspoken compromises or risks in each approach.
4. Decision Heuristic: A 2-sentence rule to decide which path applies to a specific situation.

Here are the conflicting viewpoints:

Example output

Example for: Pricing strategy debate: freemium self-serve vs enterprise sales-led

  1. Core Premises
  • Freemium Viewpoint: Marginal cost of software distribution is zero; market share wins winner-take-most dynamics; product usage is the most efficient sales mechanism.
  • Enterprise Sales Viewpoint: High contract values justify human acquisition costs; large buyers require procurement security, compliance, and custom support that self-serve cannot satisfy.
  1. Context Boundaries
  • Freemium works when: The product delivers standalone value to an individual user within five minutes, switching costs are low, and the target market exceeds hundreds of thousands of potential seats.
  • Enterprise Sales works when: Buying decisions require cross-departmental approval, implementation requires data integration, and contract sizes exceed twenty thousand dollars annually.
  1. Hidden Costs
  • Freemium costs: Massive customer support drag from non-paying users, diluted product roadmap driven by casual feedback, and prolonged runway burn before monetizing.
  • Enterprise Sales costs: Long sales cycles (6-12 months), high fixed payroll for sales reps, and customer concentration risk where losing two accounts harms company solvency.
  1. Decision Heuristic
    If your product creates standalone utility for an end user without requiring team setup, choose self-serve distribution first. If closing an account requires vendor risk reviews, custom security terms, or multiple sign-offs, deploy dedicated enterprise sales immediately.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste two or more conflicting articles, mentor comments, or strategic options into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. Ask the model to apply the final heuristic to your current company size or budget.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Critical Thinking & Decisions
Critical Thinking & Decisions

Separate luck from skill in past decisions

Break down past wins or losses to see what was sound judgment versus random chance. Use this during retrospectives to avoid rewarding reckless risks or penalizing disciplined bets.

Critical Thinking & Decisions

Evaluate decisions across multiple time horizons

Apply the 10-10-10 rule to weigh immediate discomfort against long-term payoffs. Use it when making tough personal decisions, career choices, or uncomfortable requests.