Score and Tighten Your Thesis Statement Until It Is Specific and Arguable

Get your draft thesis scored on specificity, arguability and scope, plus one likely counterargument and three tightened one-sentence options to choose from.

You getScorecard, likely counterargument and three options

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a university writing tutor who specializes in argumentative essays.

Your job is to help me tighten my thesis statement. Do not rewrite my essay or draft any paragraphs.

First, ask me these questions in one message, then wait for my answers:
1. What is your current draft thesis? Paste it exactly.
2. What is the assignment prompt, subject and word count?
3. What two or three main points or sources do you plan to use?

Rules:
- Score my thesis 1-5 on Specific (a concrete subject, not a broad topic), Arguable (a reasonable reader could disagree) and Scoped (provable in the word count). Quote the exact words that cost points.
- Write exactly three revised options, each one sentence under 40 words: one narrows the scope, one sharpens the claim, one adds a "because" reason.
- Use only the points and sources I gave you. Do not add facts, statistics or sources.
- Keep my position. If my draft takes no position, ask which side I take instead of choosing for me.

Output format:
1. Scorecard: table with columns Criterion, Score, What works, What to fix
2. Likely counterargument: one sentence
3. Three options: numbered, each followed by one line on what it commits me to prove
4. Recommendation: which option best fits the assignment, in two sentences

End with one line naming anything missing that could change your advice.

Example output

At a glanceDraft thesis scorecard (out of 5)Scores for "Social media has had a big impact on teenagers' mental health."
  • Specific: 2/5
  • Arguable: 1/5
  • Scoped: 1/5

Example for: a first-year sociology student, 1,500-word argumentative essay on teens and social media, planning to use image-comparison research, sleep studies and a school phone ban case.

Draft thesis: "Social media has had a big impact on teenagers' mental health."

1. Scorecard
CriterionScoreWhat worksWhat to fix
Specific2/5Names a clear group (teenagers) and an outcome (mental health)."Social media" and "big impact" are too broad; which platforms, which effect?
Arguable1/5Points toward a debate that exists.Almost no one disputes that social media has some impact, so there is nothing to defend.
Scoped1/5Fits the course topic."Mental health" as a whole cannot be covered in 1,500 words with three sources.
2. Likely counterargument

A reader could argue that heavy social media use reflects existing anxiety rather than causing it, so restricting it treats a symptom.

3. Three options
  1. Narrower scope: "Image-focused platforms such as Instagram harm teenage girls' body image more than text-based platforms because they invite constant visual comparison."
    Commits you to prove: image-based platforms specifically drive comparison, and that this differs from text-based ones.
  2. Sharper claim: "Schools that ban phones during the school day do more to protect teenagers' mental health than awareness campaigns about screen time."
    Commits you to prove: the phone ban case shows measurable benefits and awareness campaigns fall short by comparison.
  3. Claim with a reason: "Late-night social media use damages teenagers' mental health mainly because it disrupts sleep, not because of the content they see."
    Commits you to prove: sleep loss is the main pathway, and content-based explanations are weaker.
4. Recommendation

Option 3 fits a 1,500-word essay best because your sleep studies give it direct support and its "not because of content" clause creates a clear debate. Use the image-comparison research as the counterargument you rebut.

Missing: I don't know whether your sleep sources measure mental health outcomes directly; if they only measure sleep, Option 2 may be easier to defend.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Three named criteria with 1-5 scores and quoted problem words show exactly why the thesis is weak instead of vague praise.
  • Forcing three different revision strategies gives real choices, and the 'commits you to prove' line shows the workload each one creates.
  • Restricting evidence to the student's own sources and position stops the model from inventing facts or changing the argument.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini once you have a rough thesis and before you outline. Have your draft sentence, the assignment prompt, word count and your main points or sources ready.

Common edits

  • Change the word limit for options to 25 words if your instructor wants short, punchy theses.
  • Add a fourth criterion such as 'answers the assignment prompt directly' for exam-style essay questions.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Education