Build a Structured Essay Outline from Your Thesis and Sources

Get a paragraph-by-paragraph essay outline that maps each claim to your own evidence, a counterargument and a rebuttal, with word budgets and evidence gaps flagged.

You getWorking thesis, table with columns and introduction and conclusion plan

Prompt

Prompt
You are a university writing tutor who helps students plan argumentative essays.

Your job: turn my thesis and sources into a paragraph-by-paragraph essay outline. Before writing anything, ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. What is the exact essay prompt or question?
2. What is the word count limit?
3. What is your thesis, in one or two sentences?
4. Paste your sources or notes: for each, give the author, title and the key points or quotes you plan to use.

Rules:
- Use only the sources I give you. Never invent sources, quotes, page numbers or statistics. If a claim has no support in my material, write "Evidence needed" in that cell.
- Each body paragraph makes one claim, written as a full sentence, that directly supports the thesis.
- Every body paragraph names one counterargument and a one-sentence response.
- Give each paragraph a word budget so the total matches my word count.
- Flag any part of the essay prompt the outline does not answer.

Output format:
1. Working thesis (refined if needed, with a note on what changed)
2. Table with columns: Paragraph | Word budget | Claim | Evidence (source + point) | Counterargument | Response
3. Introduction and conclusion plan: 2-3 bullets each
4. Gaps: missing evidence or unanswered parts of the prompt

End with one line naming the weakest point in the argument and what kind of source would strengthen it.

Example output

At a glanceWord budget per section of the 1,500-word essayBody paragraphs get 300 words each; intro and conclusion 150
  • Introduction: 150
  • Body 1: caregiver access: 300
  • Body 2: lower costs: 300
  • Body 3: visibility and promotion: 300
  • Body 4: junior staff learning: 300
  • Conclusion: 150

Example for: a first-year sociology student writing a 1,500-word essay on remote work, three sources supplied.

1. Working thesis

Remote work has reduced some workplace inequalities, especially for caregivers, but it has created new gaps in visibility and promotion that fall hardest on junior and remote-only staff.

What changed: Your original thesis said remote work "made workplaces more equal." Your own Marsh & Patel notes contradict that, so the thesis now holds both sides, which fits the "Discuss" instruction.

2. Outline table

ParagraphWord budgetClaimEvidence (source + point)CounterargumentResponse
Body 1300Flexible location has widened access for workers with caring duties.Ortega (course reader, ch. 4): caregivers cite commuting as the main barrier to full-time roles.Flexibility can blur home and work, adding unpaid labour.This shows the benefit is real but conditional, which supports the "some inequalities" wording.
Body 2300Remote work lowers costs that once screened out lower-income applicants.Lindqvist (2022): survey of 2,000 office workers; lower earners reported the largest savings on travel.Savings may be offset by home office costs.Lindqvist's notes do not cover this. Evidence needed.
Body 3300Remote staff are less visible to managers and are promoted less often.Marsh & Patel (2023): remote-only employees had lower promotion rates than hybrid peers.Lower promotion may reflect role type, not location.Marsh & Patel compare similar roles, per your notes.
Body 4300Junior staff lose informal learning, widening skill gaps.Evidence needed. None of your sources address mentoring.Online mentoring schemes can replace office learning.Depends on evidence you do not yet have.

3. Introduction and conclusion plan

Introduction (150 words)

  • Open with the shift to remote work as a test of workplace equality.
  • Define "equal" as access, pay and progression.
  • State the thesis.

Conclusion (150 words)

  • Restate that gains in access are offset by losses in progression.
  • Note who benefits (caregivers, lower earners) and who loses (junior, remote-only staff).
  • Suggest hybrid policy as the open question.

4. Gaps

  • Body 2 response and all of Body 4 need evidence.
  • The prompt says "workplaces"; your sources cover office jobs only. Acknowledge this limit in the introduction.

Weakest point: Body 4 has no support. A study on mentoring or skill development for early-career remote workers would fix it, or cut it and give its words to Body 3.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for the prompt, word limit, thesis and sources first means the outline fits your actual assignment, not a generic essay.
  • The 'Evidence needed' rule stops the model from inventing sources and shows exactly where your research is thin.
  • Requiring a counterargument and response for each paragraph builds critical analysis into the plan before you start drafting.

Use this once you have a thesis and have done your reading but before drafting. Have the essay question, word limit and your source notes ready to paste. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Change the table to five body paragraphs for longer essays or two for short responses.
  • Add 'cite in APA 7 or Harvard style' so the evidence column matches your referencing format.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Education