Audit a business memo using the Pyramid Principle

Evaluate and restructure a bottom-heavy draft memo into Barbara Minto's Pyramid Principle structure, putting recommendations front and center.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a former management consulting engagement manager. Audit the draft memo pasted below against Barbara Minto's Pyramid Principle framework.

Rules:
- Check whether the core recommendation or governing thought appears in the very first paragraph.
- Verify the SCQA structure (Situation, Complication, Question, Answer) in the introduction.
- Evaluate the supporting arguments for MECE (Mutually Exclusive, Collectively Exhaustive) grouping.
- Identify buried conclusions and chronological narrative drift.
- Provide an explicit revision outline rearranging the memo into top-down pyramid order.

Output format:### Structural Audit
- Governing Thought Status: (Pass/Fail and explanation)
- SCQA Alignment: (Assessment of each component)
- MECE Evaluation: (Assessment of supporting pillars)

### Recommended Top-Down Outline
1. Executive Summary (Answer first)
2. Supporting Pillar 1
3. Supporting Pillar 2
4. Supporting Pillar 3
5. Next Actions and Timeline

The draft memo is pasted below:

Example output

Example for: an internal memo on consolidating software vendors

Structural Audit
  • Governing Thought Status: Fail. The recommendation to terminate two redundant CRM contracts is buried in the final paragraph after four pages of vendor history.
  • SCQA Alignment:

    • Situation: Present, but spans three overly long background paragraphs.
    • Complication: Weakly stated; licensing cost increases are treated as an afterthought.
    • Question: Implicit rather than explicit ("How do we reduce tooling spend without slowing sales operations?").
    • Answer: Missing from the top entirely.
  • MECE Evaluation: Overlapping. Costs and user seat adoption are split across three separate sections instead of being grouped systematically by financial impact, technical integration, and change management.
Recommended Top-Down Outline
  1. Executive Summary (Answer first)
    Consolidate sales operations onto HubSpot by Q3 to reduce annual software spend by $140,000 while eliminating duplicated customer data.
  2. Financial Impact: Direct Cost Reductions
    Elimination of redundant seats and lower per-user licensing fees across the commercial organization.
  3. Operational Efficiency: Unified Pipeline Data
    Single source of truth for marketing attribution and pipeline tracking, cutting manual sync errors.
  4. Migration Feasibility: 60-Day Rollout Plan
    Data export protocols, API connector testing, and staff training schedules designed to avoid revenue disruption.
  5. Next Actions and Timeline
    Sign vendor termination notices by May 15 and begin sandbox data migration by June 1.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste your full draft memo directly following the prompt in Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini. For an immediate rewrite, follow up by asking the model to write out the full revised memo based on the approved outline.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Writing