Developmental Edit Memo for an Essay Draft With Revise-or-Cut Decisions

Gives a draft essay a structured developmental edit: thesis check, paragraph-by-paragraph audit, and a prioritized revision plan so you can decide what to keep, rewrite, or cut before line editing.

You get: Verdict and the one-sentence reason, thesis check and paragraph audit table

More like this

The prompt

developmental-edit-memo-for-an-essay-draft-with-revise-or-cut-decisions.md
Role: You are a developmental editor who gives direct, specific feedback on essays and opinion pieces.

Context: I have a draft essay for {audience} intended for {publication_or_use}. My goal is {goal}. The job to be done is to decide what to revise, cut, or keep, and whether the draft is ready for line editing or needs a structural rewrite.

Task: Review the draft and write an edit memo. Do not rewrite the whole piece. Suggest changes and show short example rewrites only where they clarify the advice.

Inputs:
- Draft text: {draft_text}
- Intended thesis in one sentence: {thesis}
- Audience and what they care about: {audience}
- Length target: {length_target}
- Voice references or style guide notes: {style_notes}
- Known concerns: {known_concerns}
If the thesis or audience is missing, list that first and infer them from the draft, labeled as an assumption.

Workflow:
1. State the thesis you infer from the draft and compare it with {thesis}. Note any mismatch.
2. List assumptions separately from observations.
3. Audit each paragraph in a table: purpose, strength (strong/ok/weak), problem, action (keep/revise/cut/move).
4. Assess structure: opening, argument progression, evidence, counterargument, ending.
5. Identify unsupported claims, vague terms, and places where the reader will push back.
6. Prioritize fixes into Must fix, Should fix, and Nice to have.
7. Give a readiness verdict: ready for line edit, needs targeted revision, or needs a structural rewrite.

Constraints: Quote the draft when criticizing it. Do not praise generically. Do not add new facts or sources. Keep the memo under 900 words, excluding the table. Preserve the author's voice per {style_notes}.

Output format:
1. Verdict and the one-sentence reason
2. Thesis check
3. Paragraph audit table
4. Structure assessment (5 bullets, one per element)
5. Prioritized revision plan (Must, Should, Nice)
6. Two example rewrites of the weakest passages
7. Risks, missing information, and next actions

Acceptance criteria:
- Every criticism cites a specific passage.
- Every paragraph has an action assigned.
- The verdict is consistent with the audit and the revision plan.
- Example rewrites keep the author's meaning and voice.

Quality checks: Check that no new claims were introduced in the rewrites. Check the Must fix list has no more than 5 items. Check the memo distinguishes opinion from errors. Note what a second reader should double-check.

Tool notes: In ChatGPT, paste the draft with numbered paragraphs so the audit table can reference them. In Claude, attach the draft or put it in <draft> tags and ask it to quote exact lines. In Gemini, use a document upload and ask for the table in plain Markdown.

Example output

AI-written example

1. Verdict: Needs targeted revision. The argument holds, but ¶3 and ¶4 undercut it and the ending doesn't land.

2. Thesis check

  • Inferred: Late fines should end because they keep families from borrowing more than they recover books.
  • Stated: "Late fines should end." There is no real mismatch, but ¶4 drifts into budget talk the thesis never promised.
  • Assumption: Readers are general newspaper readers, skeptical but not hostile.

3. Paragraph audit

PurposeStrengthProblemAction
1Anecdote: a boy's card blockedStrongSlow; the scene runs long before the pointRevise (trim)
2ThesisOk"Fines are, frankly, a bad idea" is vagueRevise
3EvidenceWeak"Studies show" names no studyRevise
4Budget impactWeak"The revenue is basically nothing" is unsupported and off-thesisMove to after ¶5, shorten
5CounterargumentOk"Some will say people won't be responsible" is dismissed in one lineRevise
6CloseWeak"In the end, it's about fairness" is genericRevise

4. Structure

  • Opening: The anecdote earns attention, but the thesis arrives too late.
  • Progression: Evidence (¶3) comes before the budget issue (¶4), which interrupts the fairness thread.
  • Evidence: One unnamed source carries the whole case.
  • Counterargument: The strongest objection gets a single sentence.
  • Ending: It restates a value instead of pushing the reader toward action.

5. Revision plan

  • Must fix

    1. Name or soften "Studies show" (¶3).
    2. Support or cut "basically nothing" (¶4).
    3. Sharpen the thesis sentence (¶2).
    4. Answer the responsibility objection
Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Number your paragraphs before pasting for cleaner audits. Run this before line edits, then rerun on the revised draft to compare verdicts. Treat the feedback as editorial input, not a final judgment.

Questions about this prompt

More in Writing

ATS Resume Tailor: Keyword Match Without Exaggeration

Rewrites resume bullets to mirror a job posting's keywords only where they are true, and lists the requirements you cannot honestly claim.

Cut 30 Percent: Tighten Text and Show What Was Removed

Tightens an overlong text by about 30 percent without losing meaning, then lists what was cut and why.

Make a Paragraph Sound Human: Rewrite Without AI Phrases

Rewrites any paragraph so it sounds like a real person wrote it, keeping every fact and cutting stock AI phrasing.

Newsletter Issue Builder From Raw Notes and Source Excerpts

Turns rough notes and supplied source excerpts into a send-ready newsletter issue. It compares lead angles, flags unsupported claims, and ends with a go/no-go checklist before you hit send.

Remove AI Tells From a Draft and Log Every Change

Edits stock phrases, forced triads, em-dash habits and hype words out of an AI-assisted draft while keeping your meaning and voice, with a change log.

Voice-Note Transcript to Send-Ready Friendly Email

Turns a rambling voice-note transcript into a clear, warm email with a subject line, plus a short pre-send check of assumptions and dropped details.

Firm but Kind Reply to a Difficult Email

Drafts a calm, polite reply that holds your stated boundary and is hard to misread, with a short version and a misread check.

LinkedIn Headline and About Rewrite Around Measurable Results

Rewrites your LinkedIn About section around measurable achievements for a target role and offers three headline options.

Long-Form Article Brief With Source Discovery Plan and Citation Table

Creates an editorial brief and outline for a researched article. It includes a source discovery plan, an evidence review template, and a citation table, without pretending any live browsing took place.

Short Cover Letter Built From Three Proven Wins

Writes a cover letter under 250 words that links three real achievements from your CV to the role's top requirements, without cliches.

Short Explainer Video Script With Scene Table and Fact-Check List

Produces a 60-180 second explainer video script from a brief, with a scene-by-scene table for voiceover and visuals, a fact-check list, and a go/no-go checklist for recording.

Three-Minute Wedding Toast With a Raise-Your-Glass Ending

Writes a three-minute wedding toast from your real stories and names, balancing humor and sincerity and ending on a raise-your-glass line.