Write Three Headline and Subject Line Options That Match Your Draft

Paste a draft and get three headlines and three email subject lines in Direct, Curiosity and Benefit styles, with character counts and the promise each makes.

Prompt

Prompt
You are an experienced copy editor who writes headlines and email subject lines that match what the text actually delivers.

I will paste a draft (article, blog post, newsletter or email) right after this message. Read all of it, then write three headline options and three subject line options.

Rules:
1. Write one option in each of three styles: Direct (states the main point plainly), Curiosity (raises a question the draft answers), Benefit (names what the reader gains).
2. Give the exact character count, including spaces, for every option. Keep headlines under 70 characters and subject lines under 50.
3. For each option, state in one sentence the promise it makes to the reader, then point to the line or section of the draft that keeps it. If nothing in the draft keeps the promise, rewrite the option.
4. No clickbait, all caps, exclamation marks, or numbers that do not appear in the draft.
5. Reuse the draft's own key terms so search results and inbox previews match the content.

Output format:## Headlines
Table with columns: Style | Headline | Characters | Promise | Where the draft delivers it## Subject lines
Same table, with Subject line in place of Headline.## Recommendation
Two sentences naming the strongest headline and subject line and why.

End with one line flagging any claim in the draft that looks weak or unsupported, since a headline built on it would overclaim.

Example output

At a glanceHeadline and subject line length by styleCharacter counts for the three headlines and three subject lines
  • Headline: Direct: 52
  • Headline: Curiosity: 59
  • Headline: Benefit: 51
  • Subject: Direct: 39
  • Subject: Curiosity: 44
  • Subject: Benefit: 32

Example for: a 1,100-word blog post by an operations lead at a 40-person software firm about replacing two weekly status meetings with written updates.

Headlines

StyleHeadlineCharactersPromiseWhere the draft delivers it
DirectWe Replaced Two Weekly Meetings with Written Updates52Explains what the team changed and how.Section "The switch" describes the Monday template and Thursday thread.
CuriosityWhat Happened When Our Team Stopped Holding Status Meetings59Reports the real results, good and bad."What we gained" and "What we lost" sections.
BenefitHow We Got 3 Hours a Week Back with Written Updates51Shows where the saved time came from."Time logs showed about 3 hours per person per week back."

Subject lines

StyleSubject lineCharactersPromiseWhere the draft delivers it
DirectWe cut two status meetings. Here's how.39Gives a repeatable method.The five-question update template near the end.
CuriosityWhat we lost when we dropped status meetings44Admits a real downside."What we lost: the quick hallway decisions after standup."
Benefit3 hours a week back, per person32Quantifies the time saved for each person.Same time-log line as the Benefit headline.

Recommendation

The Direct headline is strongest because it states exactly what the post covers and suits search, where people look up "replace status meetings." For email, use the Curiosity subject line: it stands out in an inbox and is honest, since the draft gives a full section to the downside.

Watch out: the "3 hours per person" figure comes from one quarter of self-reported time logs, so the Benefit options lean on your weakest number. Add how it was measured or soften it to "about 3 hours."

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Three fixed styles give real variety instead of three near-identical rewrites of the same line.
  • Requiring the promise plus the passage that keeps it stops headlines from claiming more than the text delivers.
  • Exact character counts with set limits mean options fit search results and inbox previews without trimming.

Use this when a blog post, newsletter or announcement is finished but untitled. Paste the full draft into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini right after the prompt so the promises can be checked against the text.

Common edits

  • Swap the Curiosity style for a Question style, or add a fourth option written for social posts.
  • Lower the subject line limit to 40 characters if most of your readers open email on phones.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Writing