Write a Warm Counteroffer Email That Negotiates Salary and Benefits

Get a ready-to-send counteroffer email with a specific base ask, backup benefit levers, a fallback table, and a reply plan if the budget is fixed.

You getSubject line, email body and table

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a recruiter turned salary negotiation coach.

Help me write a counteroffer email for a job offer. First ask me these questions in one message, then wait for my answers:
1. What are the role, the location, and the full offer (base, bonus, equity, sign-on, PTO, start date, other benefits)?
2. What market range did you find, and where did it come from?
3. What are your top 2-3 priorities and your walk-away number?
4. Who receives the email, and how warm has the process been?

Rules:
- Open with real enthusiasm for the role in 1-2 sentences. Do not apologize.
- Make one specific base ask, justified only by the range and skills I give you. Never invent figures or competing offers.
- Add 1-2 non-base levers (sign-on, equity, bonus, PTO, remote days) so the recruiter has options.
- Keep the body under 200 words and end with a question inviting a call.
- Use no ultimatums, and never reveal my walk-away number.

Output format:
1. Subject line
2. Email body
3. Table: Lever | My ask | Acceptable fallback
4. Two sentences on how to reply if they say the budget is fixed

End with one line flagging any missing info. Note that this is general guidance, not financial or legal advice. Suggest an employment lawyer for contract terms like non-competes.

Example output

At a glanceCounteroffer asks vs acceptable fallbacksSenior product designer offer, Denver: $118,000 base, 15 PTO days
ItemMy askAcceptable fallback
Base salary$132,000$126,000
Sign-on bonus$10,000$6,000 if base lands at $126,000
PTO20 days18 days, or 20 days after year one
Bonus targetKeep 10%Keep 10%

Example for: a senior product designer in Denver offered $118,000 base, 10% bonus, no sign-on, 15 PTO days. The market range found was $125,000-$140,000 (Levels.fyi plus two peers). Priorities are base and time off. The email goes to a friendly in-house recruiter.

1. Subject line

Re: Senior Product Designer Offer – A Few Questions Before I Sign

2. Email body

Hi Dana,

Thank you again for the offer. After meeting the team, I'm genuinely excited about the redesign of the onboarding flow and want to make this work.

I've reviewed the full package carefully. Based on market data for senior product designers in Denver, which puts the range at $125,000-$140,000, and on my six years leading B2B design systems, I'd like to ask for a base salary of $132,000.

I'm also flexible on how we get there. If base is tight, a $10,000 sign-on bonus would help close the gap. Increasing PTO from 15 to 20 days would also matter a lot to me.

Would you have 15 minutes this week to talk it through? I'm confident we can land on something that works for both sides, and I'd love to give you a quick yes.

Best,
Priya Nandakumar

3. Trade-off table
LeverMy askAcceptable fallback
Base salary$132,000$126,000
Sign-on bonus$10,000$6,000 if base lands at $126,000
PTO20 days18 days, or 20 days after year one
Bonus targetKeep 10%Keep 10%
4. If they say the budget is fixed

"I understand. Could we look at a one-time sign-on bonus and the extra PTO days instead, since neither changes the salary band?" If both are a firm no, ask for a written six-month compensation review with clear criteria.

Missing info: you didn't mention equity or a remote policy. If either is on the table, it could be another lever. This is general guidance, not financial or legal advice. Have an employment lawyer review any non-compete or IP clauses.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for the full offer, market range and priorities first ties the counter to real numbers instead of a vague request for more.
  • Requiring non-base levers gives the recruiter ways to say yes when the salary band is fixed.
  • The fallback table and fixed-budget reply prepare you for the call, not just the email.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini right after you get a written offer. Have the full offer details, a market range from salary sites or peers, and your priorities ready.

Common edits

  • Ask for a shorter phone script version to use if the recruiter calls instead of replying by email.
  • Swap the levers to equity, remote days or a title change if those matter more to you than sign-on or PTO.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Career & Job Search