Respond to a Counteroffer After Resigning Without Deciding on Money Alone

You get a table checking your original reasons for leaving against the counteroffer, a clear accept or decline recommendation, and a ready-to-send reply.

Prompt

Prompt
You are an experienced career coach who has helped many people handle counteroffers after resigning.

My current employer made me a counteroffer after I resigned. Help me decide whether to accept it, then draft my reply. Before giving any advice, ask me these questions in one numbered message and wait for my answers:
1. Why did you start looking to leave, in order of importance?
2. What does the counteroffer include (pay, title, scope, timing), and what does the new offer include?
3. What did your manager say when you resigned?
4. What is your deadline, and are you leaning one way?

Rules:
- Mark each original reason as Fixed, Partly fixed or Not fixed by the counteroffer, with one line of evidence from my answers.
- Separate money reasons from non-money reasons; if only money is fixed, say so plainly.
- Give one clear recommendation (accept or decline) and the single condition that would flip it.
- Keep the written message under 150 words: polite, firm, no repeated apologies, no criticism of either employer.

Output format:
1. Reasons table: Reason | Money or non-money | Status | Evidence
2. Decision questions I still need to answer honestly (3 max)
3. Recommendation and flip condition
4. Written message
5. Talking points for the live conversation (4 bullets)

End with one line naming any assumption you made or information that is missing.

Example output

At a glanceReasons for leaving vs. the counterofferOnly the pay reason is fully fixed, so the recommendation is to decline.
ItemReasonStatus
Path to senior analystSame title, promotion talk in Q3Not fixed
Manager cancels 1:1sSame manager, no changeNot fixed
Pay below market$72,000 to $82,800Fixed
No modeling workVague "more project work"Partly fixed

Example for: a data analyst with 3 years at a logistics firm, countered with a 15% raise after accepting an offer elsewhere.

1. Reasons table
ReasonMoney or non-moneyStatusEvidence
No path to senior analystNon-moneyNot fixedCounteroffer keeps the same title; promotion "to be discussed in Q3"
Manager cancels 1:1s, little feedbackNon-moneyNot fixedSame manager, no change offered
Pay below marketMoneyFixed$72,000 to $82,800, close to new offer of $84,000
Stuck on reporting, no modeling workNon-moneyPartly fixedVague promise of "more project work"
2. Decision questions to answer honestly
  1. If the raise had come six months ago with nothing else changed, would you have stopped looking?
  2. Do you trust a Q3 promotion talk from a manager who skipped your last four 1:1s?
  3. What excites you about the new role beyond the salary?
3. Recommendation

Decline. Only one of your four reasons is fully fixed, and it is the money one. Your top two reasons are untouched.

Flip condition: a written senior analyst title and a new reporting line, effective within 30 days.

4. Written message

Subject: Re: Your offer

Hi Dana,

Thank you for the counteroffer and for the time you spent putting it together. I appreciate it, and I have thought it through carefully.

I have decided to stay with my decision and move to the new role. It offers the growth in modeling work I have been looking for, and that was the main reason for my move.

My last day remains June 14. Over the next two weeks I will document the weekly freight reports and walk Sam through the dashboard refresh so the handover is smooth.

Thank you for three good years.

Best,
Maya

5. Talking points
  • Thank Dana first and acknowledge the effort behind the offer.
  • Say the decision is about growth in your work, not only pay.
  • Do not reopen negotiation; if pressed, repeat that your decision is final.
  • Move to handover plans and confirm your last day.

Assumption: the new employer's offer is signed and not conditional on references still pending.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • The reasons table forces each original reason to be checked against the offer, so a raise can't hide unsolved problems.
  • Separating money from non-money reasons shows plainly when only pay changed.
  • A flip condition makes the recommendation testable instead of a vague pros-and-cons list.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini right after you get a counteroffer. Have both offers' details, your real reasons for leaving and your deadline ready to answer the questions.

Common edits

  • Ask for an accept version that sets written conditions, like a title change date.
  • Request a short Slack or text version instead of an email.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Career & Job Search