Compare Two Job Offers Side by Side with a Weighted Total Value Score
You get a side-by-side table of both offers' yearly value, a weighted score based on your own priorities with every calculation shown, and a clear winner.
Prompt
Act as a career advisor who compares job offers on numbers, not gut feel.
Your job: help me compare two job offers on total value. First, ask me these questions in one numbered message, then wait for my answers:
1. For each offer: base salary, bonus, equity, signing bonus and retirement match.
2. For each offer: my health insurance cost, paid time off and days in the office per week.
3. For each offer: one-way commute time and daily cost, plus title, team and realistic growth path.
4. My top factors (e.g. pay, flexibility, growth, commute) with weights adding up to 100.
Rules:
- Convert every item to a yearly dollar figure where possible and show the formula.
- Value commute time at my hourly rate (base pay / 2080) and show the math.
- Count unvested or private equity at a discount and state the discount used.
- Score each factor 1-10 per offer, multiply by my weight and show every line.
- Flag missing numbers instead of guessing.
Output format:
1. Total compensation table: item, Offer A, Offer B, difference.
2. Weighted score table: factor, weight, A score, B score, A weighted, B weighted.
3. Result: winner, margin, and the one change that would flip it.
4. Three questions to ask before accepting or negotiating.
End with a short note on assumptions and missing data. This is not financial or tax advice; see a tax professional for complex equity or relocation decisions.Example output
Tips and common edits
Why this works
- Turns every perk, commute and equity grant into a yearly dollar figure, so the two offers are measured on the same scale.
- Uses your own weights rather than generic ones, so the winner reflects what you actually care about.
- Shows every formula and names the one change that would flip the result, which gives you a specific point to negotiate.
Use when you hold two offers and need to decide or negotiate. Have both offer letters, benefits summaries and commute details ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.
Common edits
- Add a third offer column, or include your current job as a baseline.
- Swap in a different hours figure or currency for part-time roles or jobs outside the US.
Prompt details
- By
- Prompts-GPT editors
- Published
Did this prompt work?
Keep exploring
More like this
Answer Salary Expectation Questions and Negotiate Pay in Job Interviews
Get word-for-word lines for deflecting early salary questions, naming a range based on your data, declining to share current pay and countering a low offer.
Respond to a Counteroffer After Resigning Without Deciding on Money Alone
You get a table checking your original reasons for leaving against the counteroffer, a clear accept or decline recommendation, and a ready-to-send reply.
Write a Warm Counteroffer Email That Negotiates Salary and Benefits
Get a ready-to-send counteroffer email with a specific base ask, backup benefit levers, a fallback table, and a reply plan if the budget is fixed.
Build a Raise Case and Meeting Script from Your Accomplishments
Turns your pasted accomplishments into a one-page evidence summary tied to business impact, a short meeting script, and ready answers to the three most likely pushbacks.
Explain a Technical Engineering Problem to Non-Technical Managers in a One-Page Brief
Turns your pasted technical notes into a one-page brief with plain-English context, business impact, a costed options table and one clear recommendation.
Turn Rough Nursing Shift Notes into a Structured SBAR Handover
Get a per-patient SBAR handover built only from your own notes, with missing vitals, meds due and pending results flagged before you hand off.