Compare Two Job Offers Side by Side with a Weighted Total Value Score

You get a side-by-side table of both offers' yearly value, a weighted score based on your own priorities with every calculation shown, and a clear winner.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a career advisor who compares job offers on numbers, not gut feel.

Your job: help me compare two job offers on total value. First, ask me these questions in one numbered message, then wait for my answers:
1. For each offer: base salary, bonus, equity, signing bonus and retirement match.
2. For each offer: my health insurance cost, paid time off and days in the office per week.
3. For each offer: one-way commute time and daily cost, plus title, team and realistic growth path.
4. My top factors (e.g. pay, flexibility, growth, commute) with weights adding up to 100.

Rules:
- Convert every item to a yearly dollar figure where possible and show the formula.
- Value commute time at my hourly rate (base pay / 2080) and show the math.
- Count unvested or private equity at a discount and state the discount used.
- Score each factor 1-10 per offer, multiply by my weight and show every line.
- Flag missing numbers instead of guessing.

Output format:
1. Total compensation table: item, Offer A, Offer B, difference.
2. Weighted score table: factor, weight, A score, B score, A weighted, B weighted.
3. Result: winner, margin, and the one change that would flip it.
4. Three questions to ask before accepting or negotiating.

End with a short note on assumptions and missing data. This is not financial or tax advice; see a tax professional for complex equity or relocation decisions.

Example output

At a glanceNorthwind Health vs Brightline Software offersOffer A wins the weighted score by 6.5 points
ItemOffer A: Northwind HealthOffer B: Brightline Software
Base salary$118,000$128,000
Net yearly value$131,372$130,960
Commute hours per year64 hrs400 hrs
Paid time off25 days15 days
Weighted score69.062.5

Example for: a product designer choosing between a hybrid role at Northwind Health (Offer A) and an in-office role at Brightline Software (Offer B).

1. Total Compensation (yearly)

ItemOffer AOffer BDifference (B − A)
Base salary$118,000$128,000+$10,000
Bonus (A: 8% target)$9,440$0−$9,440
Equity ($40,000 / 4 yrs × 50% discount)$0$5,000+$5,000
401(k) match (A 5%, B 3%)$5,900$3,840−$2,060
Health premium (your cost)−$1,200−$3,000−$1,800
Commute cash cost (A $8 × 96 days; B $12 × 240 days)−$768−$2,880−$2,112
Net yearly value$131,372$130,960−$412
Commute time value (A 64 hrs × $56.73; B 400 hrs × $61.54)$3,631$24,615+$20,984
Paid time off25 days15 days−10 days

Commute hours: A = 40 min/day × 2 days × 48 weeks = 64 hrs. B = 100 min/day × 5 days × 48 weeks = 400 hrs.

2. Weighted Score

FactorWeightA scoreB scoreA weightedB weighted
Pay3578245280
Flexibility2584200100
Growth2558125200
Commute158312045
Total (÷10)10069.062.5

3. Result

Offer A wins by 6.5 points. Cash value is nearly equal (a $412 gap), so flexibility and commute decide it. Offer B's stronger growth path does not outweigh 336 extra commute hours a year.

What would flip it: if Brightline allows 3 remote days, B's flexibility rises to 7 and commute to 6. B then scores 74.5 and wins.

4. Questions to Ask Before Deciding

  1. Brightline: is a hybrid schedule possible after onboarding, and can it be written into the offer?
  2. Northwind: what percentage of the target bonus was actually paid out in the last two years?
  3. Brightline: what is the latest share valuation, and what happens to unvested equity if the company is acquired?

Assumptions and missing data: Bonus assumed paid at 100% of target. Equity discounted 50% because the company is private. Signing bonuses were not provided. The 48 working weeks figure is an estimate. Confirm health plan deductibles before deciding.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Turns every perk, commute and equity grant into a yearly dollar figure, so the two offers are measured on the same scale.
  • Uses your own weights rather than generic ones, so the winner reflects what you actually care about.
  • Shows every formula and names the one change that would flip the result, which gives you a specific point to negotiate.

Use when you hold two offers and need to decide or negotiate. Have both offer letters, benefits summaries and commute details ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Add a third offer column, or include your current job as a baseline.
  • Swap in a different hours figure or currency for part-time roles or jobs outside the US.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Career & Job Search