Write a Poem in a Traditional Form with Line-by-Line Craft Notes

You get an original poem that follows its form's real rules, plus a line-by-line table explaining meter, rhyme and word choices so you can revise it yourself.

Prompt

Prompt
You are a poet and creative writing teacher who knows traditional forms precisely.

Your job: write one poem in a form I choose, then explain the craft choices line by line so I can revise it myself.

Before writing, ask me these in one message and wait for my answers:
1. Which form? (e.g. sonnet, villanelle, haiku, ghazal, pantoum, sestina)
2. What subject, person or moment is it about?
3. What tone or mood?
4. Any images, words or details that must appear?

Rules:
- State the form's real rules first (line count, meter, rhyme scheme, refrains, syllable counts) and follow them exactly.
- Show the meter or syllable count for every line so I can check it.
- Use concrete images over abstract words; avoid stock phrases like "heart of gold" or "tears like rain".
- If you bend a rule (slant rhyme, a substituted foot), say where and why.
- Each craft note names one specific choice (a word, sound, line break or rhyme) and one alternative I could try.

Output format:
1. Form rules: short bulleted list.
2. The poem, with a title.
3. Line-by-line notes: table with columns Line, Meter/Syllables, Rhyme, Craft choice, Try instead.
4. Three revision ideas for the whole poem.

End with one line naming the weakest line or the rule that was hardest to keep.

Example output

At a glanceShakespearean sonnet structure in "Chain Grease"Three quatrains and a closing couplet, ABAB CDCD EFEF GG
  1. Quatrain 1 (ABAB)Lines 1-4Father kneels at the wheel in October cold
  2. Quatrain 2 (CDCD)Lines 5-8Close-up of greasy hands finding the stiff link
  3. Quatrain 3 (EFEF)Lines 9-12Volta: shifts from scene to the speaker
  4. Couplet (GG)Lines 13-14Returns to kneeling; lesson echoes line 2

Example for: a Shakespearean sonnet about a father fixing a child's bike, tender tone, must include "chain grease" and "October".

1. Form rules
  • 14 lines: three quatrains and a closing couplet
  • Iambic pentameter (10 syllables, da-DUM x5)
  • Rhyme scheme ABAB CDCD EFEF GG
  • A turn (volta) usually at line 9 or the couplet
2. Chain Grease

My father knelt and spun the upturned wheel
and leaned in close to hear the chain go wrong.
October cold came through the door like steel;
he hummed the bridge of some forgotten song.
His hands were black with chain grease to the wrist,
the nails rimmed dark, a knuckle split and dry;
he found the stiff link with a gentle twist
and held it up to me against the sky.
I thought that fixing things was something men
were simply born with, like the shape of ears.
I watched his hands but never learned it then,
and spent, it turns out, nearly thirty years
relearning what he taught me, kneeling there:
you listen first, then fix what needs repair.

3. Line-by-line notes
LineMeter/SyllablesRhymeCraft choiceTry instead
110, regular iambsA wheelOpens on action, not setting"turned" for "spun"
210, regularB wrongDiagnosis by ear sets up the ending"sound" instead of "go"
310, regularA steelCold as metal ties weather to the bike"like a blade" (re-rhyme)
410, regularB songHumming shows calm without saying itname the song
510, pyrrhic "to the"C wristRequired phrase placed mid-line, spondee slows itmove to line 6
610, regularD dryClose-up detail of hands"cracked" for "split"
710, regularC twist"gentle" contrasts with grease"patient twist"
810, regularD skySmall object made large against sky"to the light"
910, regularE menVolta: shifts from scene to the speaker"fathers" (re-rhyme)
1010, regularF earsOdd comparison makes the belief sound childish"color of eyes"
1110, regularE thenAdmits the speaker's failure"didn't" for "never"
1210, regularF yearsConversational "it turns out" adds wry tonecut the aside
1310, feminine startG thereReturns to kneeling image from line 1"on the floor"
1410, regularG repairLesson echoes line 2's listeningend on an image, not a moral
4. Revision ideas
  1. Replace the stated moral in line 14 with an image of the speaker fixing something now.
  2. Add one sound detail (the tick of the chain) in quatrain one.
  3. Try present tense for more immediacy.

Weakest line: line 14 explains the lesson instead of showing it.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Stating the form's rules up front gives the model a checklist it must visibly meet.
  • Per-line meter and rhyme columns let you verify the form yourself instead of trusting it.
  • Each note pairs a choice with an alternative, turning the poem into a revision lesson.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini when you want to learn a form, not just get a poem. Have a form, a subject and one or two concrete details in mind before you start.

Common edits

  • Ask for a free-verse version of the same poem to compare line breaks.
  • Request notes only on lines 1, the volta and the ending for a shorter breakdown.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Writing