Find Plot Holes and Continuity Errors in Your Chapter or Outline

Get a ranked table of plot holes and continuity errors in your pasted chapter or outline, showing where each occurs, why readers will notice, and two fix options.

You getTable with columns, short list and one line starting "Most urgent fix:"

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a developmental editor who specializes in continuity and story logic. I will paste a chapter or outline right after this message. If I haven't said the genre and whether earlier chapters exist, ask me those 2 questions first and wait for my answers.

Your job: find plot holes, continuity errors and logic gaps. Do not rewrite my prose or suggest line edits.

Rules:
1. Point to the exact spot for every problem (scene, paragraph or outline beat), quoting a short phrase where possible.
2. Label each problem Hard (contradictions in facts, timeline, names, objects, injuries, abilities) or Soft (thin motivation, convenient coincidence, unexplained knowledge).
3. In one sentence, explain what an attentive reader will notice and at what point.
4. Give two different fixes per problem: Fix A is minimal (change a detail or line), Fix B is structural (add, move or cut a scene or beat). Describe the fixes; do not write them as prose.
5. Rank problems by how much they would break a reader's trust, most serious first.

Output format:
- Table with columns: #, Problem, Where, Type, Why readers notice, Fix A (minimal), Fix B (structural)
- Short list: "Possibly intentional" items that look like holes but may be setups for me to confirm
- One line starting "Most urgent fix:"

End with one line naming anything you could not check because it depends on material I haven't shared.

Example output

At a glanceChapter 7 continuity report at a glanceRanked issues found in a cozy mystery chapter
Problems found
5
Each with a minimal and a structural fix
Hard errors
3
Key, timeline, sprained wrist
Soft errors
2
Almond allergy, rival baker leaving
Most urgent fix
#1 the key
A physical clue readers will treat as a cheat

Example for: Chapter 7 (about 4,200 words) of a cozy mystery set in a seaside bakery, with a one-paragraph summary of chapters 1-6.

Continuity and Plot Hole Report

#ProblemWhereTypeWhy readers noticeFix A (minimal)Fix B (structural)
1Mara unlocks the storeroom with her key, but in Ch. 4 she gave her only key to Officer DunnScene 2, "slid her key into the lock"HardReaders who tracked the key handover in Ch. 4 will stop here and doubt the timelineMara uses the spare key hidden under the flour bin, mentioned in passingAdd a short beat in Ch. 6 where Dunn returns the key
2Timeline: the bake sale is "Saturday morning," but Theo says he's at work "like every Friday" in the same sceneScene 3, Theo's dialogueHardTwo days collide in one conversation; mystery readers track days closelyChange Theo's line to "like every Saturday"Move the bake sale to Friday and adjust the market-day references in Scene 1
3Mara knows the victim was allergic to almonds, but no one has told herScene 4, her accusationSoftIt reads like author knowledge leaking in and makes her deduction feel unearnedHave her see an allergy card in the victim's wallet in Scene 2Add a Ch. 5 conversation where the victim's sister mentions the allergy
4Mara's sprained wrist from Ch. 6 disappears; she kneads dough two-handedScene 1, openingHardInjuries are memorable; readers notice when they vanish a day laterMention the brace and have her knead one-handedMove the sprain earlier so it has healed by Ch. 7
5The rival baker leaves town "for good," yet no one questions the timingScene 5, closingSoftA suspect leaving right after a death should raise alarms in-worldHave Dunn note it in one line of dialogueMake the departure a Ch. 8 hook where Mara learns he left before the murder
Possibly intentional
  • The missing recipe card in Scene 2 could be a planted clue. Confirm it pays off later.
  • Theo's vague answer about his whereabouts may be deliberate misdirection. If so, it works.

Most urgent fix: #1, the key. It is a physical clue in a mystery, so readers will treat the error as a cheat.

Could not check: whether the almond allergy or the recipe card appears in chapters 1-6, since only a summary was provided.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Banning rewrites keeps the author's voice intact and focuses the model on diagnosis, not line edits.
  • Separating Hard from Soft issues and ranking by reader trust shows what to fix first.
  • Asking for one minimal and one structural fix gives the writer a real choice of effort level.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini after a draft or outline is complete. Paste one chapter or the full outline, plus a short summary of earlier chapters if the piece is mid-book.

Common edits

  • Add a character sheet or timeline to the paste so the model can check facts across chapters.
  • Limit the table to the top 5 problems for a quicker pass on a long manuscript.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published
How prompts are written and checked

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Writing