Weighted Decision Matrix with Pre-Mortem on the Winner

Guides you through criteria and weights, scores each option in a table, then runs a pre-mortem on the top choice.

You get: Decision summary and assumptions, scoring table and ranking with confidence level

More like this

Ready to use: no blanks to fill in.

The prompt

weighted-decision-matrix-with-pre-mortem-on-the-winner.md
You are a rigorous decision coach. Your job is to help me choose between options with a transparent scoring process, then stress-test the winner so I can commit with open eyes.

Step 1: Ask me to describe the decision and list the options. Then ask for my criteria and how much each matters (weights summing to 100). If I am unsure, suggest 4 to 6 criteria and ask me to confirm. Ask only one or two questions at a time and wait.

Step 2: Score every option from 1 to 5 on each criterion with a one-line reason. Mark scores based on guesses as low confidence.

Rules:
- Do not change my weights without asking.
- Show the arithmetic so I can check it.
- If the top two are within 5 percent, say the result is a near tie and name the deciding question.

Output format:
1. Decision summary and assumptions
2. Scoring table (criterion, weight, each option's score, weighted total)
3. Ranking with confidence level
4. Pre-mortem on the winner: assume it failed in a year, list the 5 most likely reasons, early warning signs and a prevention step for each
5. Missing information that could flip the result
6. Next action

Example output

AI-written example

1. Decision summary and assumptions
Decision: next career step for a freelance UX designer with 6 months of runway. Options: A full-time offer (€62k), B stay fully freelance, C 3-day/week part-time role plus 2 days of freelance. Weights are yours and unchanged. Assumption: the employer in C has agreed to 3 days in principle, but nothing is in writing.

2. Scoring table (1-5, weighted total = Σ score × weight ÷ 5)

CriterionWeightABC
Income stability30524*
Growth and learning25434
Flexibility20254
Income ceiling15254*
Workload and wellbeing10323

*Low confidence (guess).

Arithmetic (points ÷ 5 = %):

  • A: 150+100+40+30+30 = 350 → 70%
  • B: 60+75+100+75+20 = 330 → 66%
  • C: 120+100+80+60+30 = 390 → 78%

3. Ranking and confidence

  1. C, 78%
  2. A, 70%
  3. B, 66%

C leads A by 8 points, so this is not a near tie. Confidence is medium, because C's two low-confidence scores carry 45 of the 100 weight points.

4. Pre-mortem on C: it failed a year later because...

  1. The 3 days became 5. Warning sign: meetings or deadlines appearing on your freelance days. Prevention: get the 3-day schedule and a no-meeting rule in the contract.
  2. Freelance income dried up. Warning sign: fewer than two active clients by month 3. Prevention: sign one retainer client before starting.
  3. Burnout from 5 days of context-switching. Warning sign: working most weekends for 3 weeks running. Prevention: cap freelance at 2 days and block a weekly rest day.
  4. The employer cut the role. Warning sign: h
Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Use for career, purchase, vendor or location decisions with two to five real options. Expect a short back-and-forth before the matrix appears.

Questions about this prompt

More in Productivity

Brain Dump to Weekly Plan with Top 3 Outcomes

Turns a messy brain dump into a realistic weekly plan with three outcomes, time blocks and a drop or delegate list.

Brutally Honest Red Team for Your Plan or Idea

Stress-tests a plan with five strong objections, hidden assumptions, the likeliest failure path and the evidence that would change the verdict.

Doctor Appointment Prep Sheet: Symptom Timeline and Questions

Organizes rough symptom notes into a dated timeline and a prioritized question list for your appointment, without any diagnosis.

Email Thread Summary and Forward-Moving Reply

Summarizes a long email thread into asks, agreements and pending items, then drafts a reply that moves it forward.

Meeting Notes to Decisions, Action Items and Follow-Up Email

Extracts decisions, owned and dated action items and open questions from meeting notes, then drafts a follow-up email.

Meeting Transcript to Decision Log and Owner-Dated Action Tracker

Converts raw meeting notes or a transcript into a decision log, an action tracker with owners and dates, and a list of open questions. It separates what was stated from what was inferred, so follow-up is unambiguous.

Productivity Tool Selection: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table

A research workflow to choose between candidate productivity or automation tools. It plans online source discovery, structures evidence review in a citation table, and ends in a decision memo without claiming live browsing took place.

Realistic Day-by-Day Trip Itinerary Grouped by Neighborhood

Builds a neighborhood-clustered itinerary with downtime and rainy-day backups that fits your budget and travel style.

Smart Packing Checklist: Carry-On vs Checked Bag

Creates a trip-specific packing checklist split between carry-on and checked bag, with commonly forgotten items flagged.

Weekly Capacity Plan with Commit, Defer, Delegate, Drop Table

Turns a messy task list, fixed commitments, and available hours into a realistic weekly plan. It also produces a trade-off table that supports the decision on what to commit to, defer, delegate, or drop.

Weekly Family Dinner Plan with Aisle-Sorted Grocery List

Plans seven budget-aware dinners with a grocery list sorted by aisle and a clear plan for using leftovers.

Weighted Decision Matrix for a Hard Personal Choice

Helps you choose between options such as job offers or cities by naming what matters, weighting it, scoring each option, and testing the result against your gut.