Productivity Tool Selection: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table

A research workflow to choose between candidate productivity or automation tools. It plans online source discovery, structures evidence review in a citation table, and ends in a decision memo without claiming live browsing took place.

You get: Source discovery plan, citation table and weighted scoring matrix with Unknown allowed

More like this

The prompt

productivity-tool-selection-source-discovery-evidence-review-and-citation-table.md
Role: You are a careful research analyst supporting a software selection decision.

Context: I must decide which tool to adopt for {use_case}. Candidates: {candidate_tools}. Decision criteria: {criteria}. The job to be done is to make a defensible adoption decision (adopt, pilot, or reject) that I can justify to {decision_audience}. Budget and constraints: {constraints}.

Task: Produce a source discovery plan, an evidence review framework, a citation table, a synthesis, and a decision recommendation.

Important honesty rule: You may not have live web access. Do not claim to have browsed, and do not invent URLs, quotes, prices, version numbers, or statistics. If you cannot verify a fact, label it Unverified and tell me exactly how to verify it. If I paste source excerpts, use only those for evidence and cite them by the label I give.

Inputs (ask for anything missing before starting):
- Use case and team size: {use_case}
- Candidate tools: {candidate_tools}
- Weighted criteria (for example integration, cost, security, learning curve): {criteria}
- Must-have requirements and deal-breakers: {constraints}
- Pasted source excerpts, if any, each with a label like S1, S2: {source_excerpts}

Workflow:
1. Assumptions: list them separately from facts I gave.
2. Source discovery plan: for each candidate, list the source types to find (official documentation, pricing page, security or compliance page, changelog, independent reviews, user community threads) and give 2-3 search queries per type. Mark which sources are primary versus secondary.
3. Evidence review: for each criterion and tool, state what evidence is needed and how to rate its reliability (High: official or primary; Medium: independent; Low: anecdotal).
4. Citation table: build a table from the excerpts I provide. If none were provided, build an empty table with the columns ready and a checklist of what to collect.
5. Synthesis: score each tool against weighted criteria only where evidence exists; show Unknown otherwise.
6. Decision support: recommend adopt, pilot, or reject for each tool, with the conditions under which the recommendation changes.

Constraints: Concise and professional. No guaranteed outcomes. Distinguish evidence from opinion.

Output format:
- Assumptions and open questions
- Source discovery plan (table: Tool | Source type | Search query | Primary/Secondary)
- Citation table (Source label | Tool | Claim | Evidence type | Reliability | Verified? Y/N)
- Weighted scoring matrix with Unknown allowed
- Synthesis (max 200 words)
- Recommendation with decision conditions
- Risks, missing information, and contradictions
- Next actions (max 5) including a 2-week pilot design if pilot is recommended

Acceptance criteria:
- No fabricated URLs, quotes, or numbers.
- Every scored claim maps to a source label or is marked Unknown.
- Deal-breakers are checked explicitly per tool.
- The recommendation states what evidence would change it.

Quality checks (report pass/fail): browsing not claimed; unverified items flagged; weights sum to 100 percent; citations match the labels I supplied; risks are specific to the candidates.

Tool-specific instructions: In Perplexity or ChatGPT with search enabled, run the queries from the discovery plan and list real sources with links as you find them, marking anything you could not open. In Claude or Gemini without search, treat the plan as a checklist for me to run, and ask me to paste excerpts.

Example output

AI-written example

Assumptions and open questions

  • Assumed: 12 users, a 6-week rollout window, and that "SSO" means a requirement rather than a preference.
  • Open: the budget cap ($600/month) is unconfirmed for annual versus monthly billing. Do we need the ledger connector on day one?

Source discovery plan (no browsing performed; this is a checklist)

ToolSource typeSearch queryP/S
FlowPilotSecurity/compliance page"FlowPilot SOC 2 report request"Primary
FlowPilotPricing page"FlowPilot Business tier price per seat"Primary
TaskLoomOfficial docs"TaskLoom ledger integration setup"Primary
TaskLoomCommunity threads"TaskLoom onboarding time review"Secondary

Citation table

LabelToolClaimEvidence typeReliabilityVerified?
S1FlowPilotSSO on Business tier only; no price shownPricing pageHighY (pasted)
S2TaskLoomSOC 2 Type II available under NDASecurity pageHighY (pasted)
S3FlowPilotNative ledger, e-signature, drive connectorsDocsHighY (pasted)
S4TaskLoomSetup took about three weeksForum postLowN

Weighted scoring (1-5)

| Criterion (weight) | FlowPilot | TaskLoom |
|---

Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Run this in two passes: first to get the discovery plan, then paste the excerpts you gathered and re-run for the citation table and recommendation. Always open cited sources yourself before relying on pricing or security claims.

Questions about this prompt

More in Productivity

Competitor Landscape Research Plan with Source Discovery and Citation Table

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence review, citation table, and decision-ready synthesis for a competitor or market question, without pretending live browsing occurred.

Evidence Review Plan for a Classroom Teaching Strategy Decision

Guides source discovery, evidence review, a citation table, synthesis, and a recommendation on whether to adopt a teaching strategy. It does not claim live browsing and marks every unverified item for you to check.

Competitor Landscape Scan with Source-Backed Citation Table

Runs a structured competitor scan that starts with search queries, ranks sources by reliability, and ends with a cited comparison table and a positioning recommendation.

Competitor UX Pattern Research Plan with Evidence Table and Design Recommendation

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence log, citation table, and synthesis for comparing UX patterns across competitors, without claiming live browsing.

Parallel Research Fan-Out and Fan-In with Citation Table and Decision Memo

Splits a research question across parallel research agents, defines source discovery and evidence review steps, merges findings into a citation table, and produces a decision memo without claiming live browsing.

Research Agent Brief: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table

Directs an AI agent to plan source discovery, grade evidence, build a citation table, and support a decision without claiming live browsing occurred.

Weekly Capacity Plan with Commit, Defer, Delegate, Drop Table

Turns a messy task list, fixed commitments, and available hours into a realistic weekly plan. It also produces a trade-off table that supports the decision on what to commit to, defer, delegate, or drop.

Audience Research Source Discovery and Evidence Synthesis for Segment Prioritization

Guides you to plan source discovery, review the evidence you collect, build a citation table, and synthesize findings into a segment prioritization decision, without pretending the model browsed the web.

AI Paper Explainer with Evidence Table and Practical Takeaways

Turns a pasted AI paper abstract or text into a plain-language explanation of what is new, how it was tested, its limits and what to do with it.

AI Visibility Audit: Brand Mention and Citation Test Plan for AI Answer Engines

Design and analyze a repeatable prompt test set that checks how AI answer engines mention and cite your brand. It turns results into a citation table, evidence-based gap findings, and prioritized page and entity fixes.

Competitor and Audience Evidence Review with Citation Table and Go/No-Go Brief

A research workflow that plans online source discovery, scores evidence, builds a citation table, and ends with a decision brief, without pretending live browsing happened.

Long-Form Article Brief With Source Discovery Plan and Citation Table

Creates an editorial brief and outline for a researched article. It includes a source discovery plan, an evidence review template, and a citation table, without pretending any live browsing took place.