Brutally Honest Red Team for Your Plan or Idea

Stress-tests a plan with five strong objections, hidden assumptions, the likeliest failure path and the evidence that would change the verdict.

You get: Verdict in one sentence, five strongest objections and hidden assumptions

More like this

The prompt

brutally-honest-red-team-for-your-plan-or-idea.md
You are a skeptical red-team analyst who has seen many startups and projects fail. Your job is to attack my plan so I can decide whether to proceed, change it or stop.

Plan or idea: {paste your plan or idea here}

If you cannot tell who the customer or audience is, what resources I have or what success means, ask me up to two short questions first.

Rules:
- Be direct and specific. No praise, no filler, and no generic risks like competition exists.
- Rank the 5 objections from strongest to weakest and tie each to a detail in my plan.
- Mark every assumption as stated by me or inferred by you.
- Pick one most likely failure path and describe it as a short sequence of events.

Output format:
1. Verdict in one sentence (proceed, revise or stop) with confidence level
2. Five strongest objections (table: objection, why it is serious, how to test it cheaply)
3. Hidden assumptions (list, marked stated or inferred)
4. Most likely failure path (3 to 5 steps)
5. Evidence that would change the verdict (table: evidence, direction it moves the verdict)
6. Next 3 actions in the coming two weeks

Example output

AI-written example

1. Verdict: Revise. Confidence: 70%. The target of 100 paying shops at $29/month rests on a buyer who is hard to reach and has little reason to pay.

2. Five strongest objections

#ObjectionWhy it's seriousCheap test
1Owners post from their phones in 2 minutes and won't pay $29 for captionsYour product replaces a free habit, and ChatGPT already does itAsk 15 owners what they spend on social media now and what they'd cancel first
2Cold Instagram DMs to busy owners will get near-zero repliesYour whole acquisition plan depends on itSend 100 DMs in a week and track the reply rate. Under 3% means the channel is dead
3$2.9k MRR doesn't justify the work if churn is highShops with thin margins cancel after a slow monthOffer a 3-month prepaid price to 10 shops and see who accepts
4Captions aren't the bottleneck; photos and time areGeneric text won't improve the postsWatch 5 owners create a post and note where they get stuck
5Part-time solo support won't cover 100 small accountsEach shop will want custom tone and fixesHand-write captions for 5 shops for 2 weeks and log the hours

3. Hidden assumptions

  • Owners, not managers or agencies, make the buying decision (inferred)
  • Social media is a top-three growth worry for coffee shops (inferred)
  • $29/month is the right price (stated)
  • Cold DMs will reach owners (stated)
  • 100 paying shops in 9 months is achievable part-time (stated)
  • AI captions will sound distinct enough for each shop's brand (inferred)
  • Shops will keep paying after the first month (inferred)

4. Most likely failure path

  1. You build the MVP over 6–8 weeks before talking to any buyers.
  2. You send DMs and get a few replies and 3–5 free trials.
  3. Trial users like the captions but stop using them after two weeks because posting still takes effort.
  4. Only 1–2 shops convert to paid, and you can't tell whether the cause is price, product or channel.
  5. Savings and motivation run down by month 5, and you quit with no clear lesson.

5. Evidence that would change the verdict

EvidenceDirection
5+ of 15 owners say they'd pay $29 now, or prepayToward proceed
DM reply rate above 8%Toward proceed
Owners say photos or time, not captions, are the problemToward stop or pivot
Trial users post fewer than 3 times in 4 weeksToward stop
A local marketing agency offers to resell your productToward proceed

6. Next 3 actions (two weeks)

  1. Days 1–5: Interview 15 coffee shop owners. Ask about current spend, time and pain, and don't pitch the product.
  2. Days 3–10: Send 100 DMs offering a manual, hand-written caption pack for $29 and note the reply rate. Build nothing yet.
  3. Days 10–14: Deliver manual service to any paying shops, log hours, and decide on a stop/continue threshold, such as 5 paying shops by day 30.
Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Use before committing money or time to a business idea, launch or project. Paste the full plan, including numbers and timelines if you have them.

Questions about this prompt

More in Productivity

Brain Dump to Weekly Plan with Top 3 Outcomes

Turns a messy brain dump into a realistic weekly plan with three outcomes, time blocks and a drop or delegate list.

Doctor Appointment Prep Sheet: Symptom Timeline and Questions

Organizes rough symptom notes into a dated timeline and a prioritized question list for your appointment, without any diagnosis.

Email Thread Summary and Forward-Moving Reply

Summarizes a long email thread into asks, agreements and pending items, then drafts a reply that moves it forward.

Meeting Notes to Decisions, Action Items and Follow-Up Email

Extracts decisions, owned and dated action items and open questions from meeting notes, then drafts a follow-up email.

Meeting Transcript to Decision Log and Owner-Dated Action Tracker

Converts raw meeting notes or a transcript into a decision log, an action tracker with owners and dates, and a list of open questions. It separates what was stated from what was inferred, so follow-up is unambiguous.

Productivity Tool Selection: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table

A research workflow to choose between candidate productivity or automation tools. It plans online source discovery, structures evidence review in a citation table, and ends in a decision memo without claiming live browsing took place.

Realistic Day-by-Day Trip Itinerary Grouped by Neighborhood

Builds a neighborhood-clustered itinerary with downtime and rainy-day backups that fits your budget and travel style.

Smart Packing Checklist: Carry-On vs Checked Bag

Creates a trip-specific packing checklist split between carry-on and checked bag, with commonly forgotten items flagged.

Weekly Capacity Plan with Commit, Defer, Delegate, Drop Table

Turns a messy task list, fixed commitments, and available hours into a realistic weekly plan. It also produces a trade-off table that supports the decision on what to commit to, defer, delegate, or drop.

Weekly Family Dinner Plan with Aisle-Sorted Grocery List

Plans seven budget-aware dinners with a grocery list sorted by aisle and a clear plan for using leftovers.

Weighted Decision Matrix with Pre-Mortem on the Winner

Guides you through criteria and weights, scores each option in a table, then runs a pre-mortem on the top choice.

Business Idea Validation Sprint with a $100 Two-Week Test

Turn a business idea and target customer into a ranked list of risky assumptions, five interview questions and a $100 test to run in two weeks.