Score a Support Agent Reply Against a Quality Assurance Rubric

Get a four-criteria QA scorecard table grading tone, accuracy, completeness, and next steps, plus a ready-to-send rewrite of your support agent's reply.

You getScorecard Table, overall QA Score and rewritten Reply

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a senior customer support quality assurance lead. I will paste a customer's message and a support agent's draft reply below. Grade the draft reply against a four-criteria QA rubric and provide a rewritten version.

Rules:
- Score each criterion—Tone, Accuracy, Completeness, and Next Steps—on a 1 to 5 scale, where 5 means ready to send with no edits.
- Cite one specific phrase from the draft reply in every scorecard row to justify the score.
- Flag any policy or factual claims that cannot be verified from the customer's message alone.
- Write the improved reply in plain, empathetic language under 180 words with a clear, single next step.

Output format:
1. Scorecard Table: Markdown table with columns for Criterion, Score (1-5), Evidence from Draft, and What to Fix.
2. Overall QA Score: Total out of 20 and a one-sentence pass or revise verdict.
3. Rewritten Reply: The full, ready-to-send message.

End with one line noting any missing account context or unverified policy details.

Example output

At a glanceQA scores by criterion (out of 5)Overall 11 / 20: revise before sending
  • Tone: 2
  • Accuracy: 4
  • Completeness: 2
  • Next Steps: 3

Example for: a B2B SaaS support agent replying to a customer frustrated by a duplicate annual renewal charge.

Scorecard Table
CriterionScore (1-5)Evidence from DraftWhat to Fix
Tone2"As per our billing policy, you should have checked..."Remove defensive phrasing and acknowledge the frustration first.
Accuracy4"Your $480 renewal processed on October 12."Confirm the second charge ID if visible in the billing log.
Completeness2"We will look into this soon."State whether a refund has been initiated and the exact timeline.
Next Steps3"Let us know if you need anything else."Give a specific follow-up date and a direct confirmation action.
Overall QA Score

11 / 20 — Revise before sending. The draft sounds defensive and leaves the customer uncertain about when their money will be returned.

Rewritten Reply

Hi Maya,

I am sorry for the frustration caused by seeing two $480 renewal charges on October 12. I have reviewed your account and confirmed that the second charge was a duplicate billing error.

I have already initiated a full refund of $480 back to your Visa ending in 4219. Depending on your bank, you should see the funds appear within 3 to 5 business days.

Your annual subscription remains active with no interruption. I will follow up with you on October 17 to confirm the refund has cleared—just reply to this email if you need anything before then.

Best,
Jordan

Note: Assumes the agent verified the duplicate charge in the billing system and has permission to issue an immediate $480 refund.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Forces the model to cite exact phrases from the draft so feedback is concrete and coachable.
  • Separates tone, accuracy, completeness, and next steps into a scannable table instead of vague prose.
  • Caps the rewritten reply at 180 words with a single next step to keep the customer focused.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini before sending a sensitive reply or during weekly QA audits. Paste the customer's original message and the agent's draft reply directly below the prompt.

Common edits

  • Add your company's specific refund window or SLA rules to the prompt for stricter accuracy checks.
  • Change the 1 to 5 scale to Pass/Fail if your team uses binary QA scoring.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Customer Support