Rewrite a Landing Page Headline and Subhead in Five Direct-Response Angles

You get five headline and subhead pairs (outcome, pain, objection, comparison, specificity), each tied to a buyer belief, with character counts and a pick for which to test first.

Prompt

Prompt
You are a direct-response copywriter who writes landing page headlines for A/B tests.

Before writing, ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. Paste your current headline and subhead.
2. What do you sell, and who buys it?
3. What is the main reason buyers hesitate or say no?
4. What do they use now instead of you, and what real numbers or proof can I use?

Then write five headline and subhead pairs, one per angle: outcome, pain, objection, comparison, specificity.

Rules:
- Tie each pair to one buyer belief, written as a first-person sentence the buyer would actually say.
- Headlines under 70 characters, subheads under 140. Give the exact character count for each, spaces included.
- Use only facts and numbers I give you. If an angle needs a figure I did not provide, write "needs real figure" instead of inventing one.
- No exclamation marks, no hype words, no vague claims like "smarter" or "better" without saying how.
- Each subhead must add something the headline does not: who it is for, how it works, or proof.

Output format:
1. Table: Angle | Buyer belief | Headline | Chars | Subhead | Chars
2. Test first: the angle to run first and two sentences on why, based on my answers.
3. What to measure: one line.

End with one line listing assumptions you made and any claim I must verify before publishing.

Example output

At a glanceHeadline length by angle (characters)Character counts for each of the five headlines
  • Outcome: 46
  • Pain: 61
  • Objection: 41
  • Comparison: 55
  • Specificity: 61

Example for: Shiftwell, a staff scheduling app for independent cafes; current headline "The smarter way to schedule your team"; buyers fear switching effort; they use spreadsheets and group texts; proof: 20-minute setup, March survey of 112 users reporting about 3 hours saved weekly.

1. Headline variants
AngleBuyer beliefHeadlineCharsSubheadChars
Outcome"I lose my Sunday nights to the rota."Get 3 hours back every week on cafe scheduling46Shiftwell builds your weekly rota, texts it to staff and handles swaps, so you stop rebuilding the schedule every Sunday night.127
Pain"One sick call wrecks my whole week."Stop rebuilding the schedule every time someone calls in sick61Staff swap shifts in the app and you approve with one tap. No more group-text chains at 6 a.m.94
Objection"I don't have time to set up another tool."Switching takes 20 minutes, not a weekend41Import your staff list from a spreadsheet, and Shiftwell drafts your first rota from last week's hours.103
Comparison"My spreadsheet works fine."Your spreadsheet can't text staff when a shift opens up55Shiftwell sends alerts, handles swaps and puts a live rota on every team member's phone.88
Specificity"Every app claims to save time."112 cafe managers cut scheduling time by about 3 hours a week61Based on our March survey of Shiftwell users. Setup takes 20 minutes, and your first rota is built from last week's hours.122
2. Test first: Objection

You said the main reason buyers say no is switching effort, so the headline that removes that fear goes straight at the biggest drop-off point. It also uses your strongest verifiable fact (20-minute setup), which makes the claim easy to believe.

Run it against your current headline before testing the other four, so you have a clean baseline.

3. What to measure

Visitor-to-trial signup rate, with at least 100 signups per variant before calling a winner.

Assumptions and checks: I assumed spreadsheet import exists and that the first rota is drafted from past hours; confirm both. The "about 3 hours" figure must match your survey wording, and the 112 respondents should all be cafe managers before you print that.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Tying each variant to a first-person buyer belief forces every headline to answer a real doubt, not just sound different.
  • Character limits and exact counts make variants ready to drop into page builders and ad tools without trimming.
  • Banning invented figures and flagging gaps keeps the specificity angle honest and legally safe to publish.

Use before launching a page or ad test when the headline feels generic. Have your current copy, the main buyer objection and any real numbers ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Lower the headline limit to 40 characters for mobile hero sections or ad headlines.
  • Add a sixth angle, such as social proof or urgency, if you have real testimonials or a genuine deadline.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Writing
Writing

Turn support notes into a clear FAQ

Transform messy customer support notes or bullet points into an easy-to-read FAQ section. Use it to update help documentation or your website sales page.