Evaluate competing hypotheses on complex research questions
Weigh rival explanations systematically against source evidence using confidence levels and counter-arguments.
You getHypotheses Defined, evidence Matrix and diagnostic Analysis
Prompt
Act as a principal intelligence analyst. Using the Analysis of Competing Hypotheses methodology, evaluate the pasted research puzzle across at least three distinct explanatory hypotheses.
Rules:
- Formulate three mutually exclusive, plausible hypotheses to explain the phenomenon.
- Evaluate every piece of available evidence for consistency or inconsistency against each hypothesis.
- Assign a confidence rating (Low, Medium, High) to each hypothesis based solely on empirical evidence, not probability of occurrence.
- Emphasize diagnostic evidence that eliminates a hypothesis over evidence that merely confirms one.
Output format:
- Hypotheses Defined: H1, H2, and H3 stated in one concise sentence each.
- Evidence Matrix: Table with columns Evidence Item, H1 (Consistent/Inconsistent), H2, and H3.
- Diagnostic Analysis: Assessment of which hypothesis has the least disconfirming evidence.
- High-Impact Information Gaps: Two specific data points that would decisively disprove the leading hypothesis.
Here is the research problem and evidence:Example output
Paste your data points, operational problem, or observed anomalies directly below the prompt in Gemini, ChatGPT, or Claude. To go further, ask the model to outline an experiment to collect the two identified information gaps.
Make it repeatable
Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.
Prompt details
- By
- Prompts-GPT editors
- Published
Did this prompt work?
Keep exploring
More like this
Audit a research summary for evidence cherry picking
Inspect qualitative and quantitative research decks to detect selective reporting, omitted counter-evidence, and unvalidated generalizations.
Compare vendor options across cross-functional buying priorities
Evaluate competing software tools across technical, security, financial, and operational criteria to expose trade-offs beyond basic feature checklists.
Prepare evidence-backed answers to buying committee objections
Turn skeptical questions from finance, security, and operations buyers into clear, factual talking points with required proof assets.
Convert academic research abstracts into simple explanations
Break dense scientific abstracts down into plain, readable findings without losing the core conclusions. Perfect for applying research to work projects or personal knowledge.
Draft a non-leading user research interview guide
Develop unbiased, behavior-focused interview questions that uncover genuine user habits instead of false compliments.
Evaluate study methodology for flaws and limitations
Identify methodological weaknesses, confounding factors, and sample size limitations in published research.
- Find the strongest counterarguments to your thesis
- Turn a research report into executive Q&As
- Create a Board-Ready Executive Research Brief
- Spot Logical Fallacies and Weak Arguments in Any Opinion Piece
- Trace a Quote or Claim Back to Its Original Source Step by Step
- Build a Literature Review Matrix from Pasted Abstracts with Gaps and Contradictions