Write discussion-starting YouTube pinned comments

Craft engaging pinned comments with open questions and clear prompts that motivate viewers to leave thoughtful replies.

You getOption 1, option 2 and option 3

Prompt

Prompt
You are an audience engagement strategist for YouTube creators. Write pinned comments designed to maximize meaningful viewer replies under a video.

Rules:
- Provide 3 distinct pinned comment variations: one split-opinion debate question, one personal experience prompt, and one resource-sharing prompt.
- Keep comments concise (under 60 words each) and friendly in tone.
- Avoid generic questions like "What did you think?"; ask specific, binary or scenario-based questions that are easy to answer.
- Include a subtle secondary nudge (e.g., asking for timestamps or topic suggestions) naturally.

Output format:
- Option 1: The Debate Question (Comment text + 1 line explaining the psychological angle)
- Option 2: The Experience Prompt (Comment text + 1 line explaining the psychological angle)
- Option 3: The Crowdsource Prompt (Comment text + 1 line explaining the psychological angle)

Here is what the video is about:

Example output

Example for: a video reviewing three productivity apps

Option 1: The Debate Question
Comment text: Honest question: do all-in-one productivity apps actually keep you organized, or do you spend more time configuring dashboards than working? Drop a 1 for 'indispensable' or a 2 for 'total distraction' below.
Why it works: Lowering the barrier to entry with a 1 or 2 choice encourages quick participation while inviting strong opinions.

Option 2: The Experience Prompt
Comment text: What is the single app or analog tool you have used every single day for over two years without abandoning it? Looking for tools that survive past the initial hype phase.
Why it works: People love sharing their personal systems and being recognized as disciplined practitioners.

Option 3: The Crowdsource Prompt
Comment text: If you could take one feature from Notion and move it into Obsidian tomorrow, what would it be? Pinned reply will go to the best setup suggestion for next month's workflow teardown.
Why it works: Gives viewers an incentive to comment with specific product knowledge while sourcing ideas for future channel content.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste your video summary, title, or main takeaways into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. As a follow-up, ask the model to rewrite your favorite option to match your specific channel voice (e.g., sarcastic, academic, or high-energy).

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in YouTube, Podcasts & Video
YouTube, Podcasts & Video

Create a YouTube community poll schedule

Maintain channel engagement between major video uploads with interactive community polls designed to gather data, test ideas, and drive comments.

YouTube, Podcasts & Video

Turn a blog post into a visual video outline

Convert long-form text into an engaging, visual video outline with speaking points and camera direction. Ideal for creators repurposing articles for YouTube.