Write and Rank 15 Email Subject Lines with Preview Text for A/B Testing

You get 15 subject lines under 50 characters, each paired with preview text that adds a new fact, tagged by type, ranked, plus two ready-to-run A/B test pairs.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an email marketer who writes and tests subject lines for a living.

Your job: write 15 subject lines with matching preview text for one email, then rank them.

Before writing, ask me these questions in one numbered message and wait for my answers:
1. What is the email about, and what should readers do after opening it?
2. Who is the audience, and how do they know us?
3. Is there a real deadline, offer, price or number you can use?
4. Any words, tone or topics to avoid?

Rules:
- Every subject line is under 50 characters including spaces. Show the count.
- Preview text is 40-90 characters and adds a fact the subject line does not state. Never repeat its words.
- Tag each line Curiosity, Benefit or Urgency, with 5 of each. Use Urgency only if I gave a real deadline; otherwise replace those with Benefit and say so.
- No all caps, at most one emoji across all 15, no spammy phrases like "act now" or "free!!!".
- Use only facts I give you. Do not invent discounts, statistics, quotes or testimonials.

Output format:
1. A table ranked best to worst with columns: Rank, Subject line, Chars, Preview text, Type, Why it might win.
2. Two A/B test pairs, each comparing different types, with the metric to watch (open rate or click rate).
3. One line naming the audience assumptions your ranking depends on.

Example output

At a glanceCharacter count of top 5 ranked subject linesAll 15 lines stay under 50 characters
  • #1 Early-bird $40 off ends Friday: 30
  • #2 Make your first bowl in 6 weeks: 31
  • #3 Why your first bowl will wobble: 31
  • #4 Clay, glaze and kiln time included: 34
  • #5 Last 3 days for early-bird pricing: 34

Example for: a small pottery studio emailing 1,900 subscribers about a 6-week beginner wheel class (Tuesdays 6:30-8:30pm from May 6, 8 seats, $280, or $240 early-bird until Friday, clay and firing included, taught by Maren).

Ranked subject lines

RankSubject lineCharsPreview textTypeWhy it might win
1Early-bird $40 off ends Friday306 Tuesday evenings from May 6, clay and firing included.UrgencyReal deadline plus a number
2Make your first bowl in 6 weeks31Beginner wheel class with Maren, 8 seats, $240 until Friday.BenefitConcrete, visual outcome
3Why your first bowl will wobble31And how Maren fixes it in week one. Class opens May 6.CuriosityNames a beginner worry
4Clay, glaze and kiln time included34No supply list: $240 covers all 6 weeks if you book by Friday.BenefitRemoves hidden-cost doubt
5Last 3 days for early-bird pricing34Spring wheel class drops from $280 to $240 until Friday.UrgencyCountdown framing
6Spring wheel class, no experience needed40Tuesdays 6:30-8:30pm from May 6, 8 seats only.BenefitLowers the entry barrier
7What happens in week three26That's when your pieces go in the kiln. Class starts May 6.CuriosityShort, open loop
8Only 8 seats in the spring wheel class38Small group so Maren can watch every pair of hands. $240 by Friday.UrgencyScarcity backed by fact
9Two hours a week, one finished set34Tuesday evenings, glazed and fired by June 10.BenefitTime cost made clear
10The one thing to bring to class31Old clothes. Clay, tools and firing are covered.CuriosityPractical hook
11Learn the wheel with Maren this spring386 Tuesday evenings, max 8 people, early-bird $240.BenefitWorks if Maren is known
12Friday: your $40 discount expires33Book the spring wheel class at $240 instead of $280.UrgencyClear, but sounds salesy
13Centering clay is easier than it looks38Maren covers it in week one of the spring class.CuriosityReassuring, less specific
14Have you wanted to try the wheel?33Spring beginner class runs 6 Tuesdays from May 6.CuriosityEasy to skim past
15Spring classes start May 626Book by Friday to pay $240 instead of $280.UrgencyReads like a calendar note

A/B test pairs

  1. #1 vs #2 (Urgency vs Benefit). Send each to 15% of the list, wait 4 hours, send the winner to the rest. Watch open rate.
  2. #3 vs #4 (Curiosity vs Benefit). Same split. Watch click rate, since curiosity lines can lift opens without lifting bookings.

Assumptions: The ranking assumes most subscribers are past workshop guests who know the studio and are price-aware; a colder list may respond better to Benefit lines than Urgency.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • The 50-character cap with a visible count keeps lines readable on mobile and makes the limit easy to check.
  • Requiring preview text to add a new fact stops the common waste of repeating the subject line.
  • Equal Curiosity, Benefit and Urgency tags give you clean A/B pairs instead of 15 variations of one idea.

Use before sending a newsletter, launch or promo email. Have the email's goal, audience and any real offer or deadline ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini; paste your draft email too for sharper lines.

Common edits

  • Ask for 5 extra lines in a single type that matches your brand voice, such as Benefit only.
  • Change the 50-character cap to 35 for a list that mostly reads on phones.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Marketing