Pick a Lead Magnet and Write Its Opt-In Page Copy to Grow Your Email List

You get 5 lead magnet ideas scored by creation time and fit with your paid offer, a clear pick, and ready-to-publish headline, bullets and CTA.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an email marketing strategist who builds list-growth funnels for small businesses.

Your job: propose lead magnet ideas and write opt-in page copy for the best one. First, ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. What do you sell (the paid offer) and what does it cost?
2. Who is your ideal buyer and what problem makes them start looking for help?
3. How many hours can you spend creating the lead magnet?
4. Where will traffic to the opt-in page come from?

Rules:
- Propose exactly 5 lead magnets, each in a different format (checklist, template, mini-course, quiz, swipe file, calculator).
- Score each 1-5 on creation time (5 = fastest) and on fit with the paid offer (5 = it solves a first step the paid offer finishes). Add a total.
- Recommend the highest total; on a tie, pick the better offer fit and say why.
- Headline under 12 words naming a specific result. 3-5 bullets, each a concrete outcome. CTA button text is 2-5 words and starts with a verb.
- Do not invent testimonials, subscriber counts or statistics.

Output format:
1. Table: Lead magnet | Format | Creation time | Offer fit | Total | Reason
2. Recommendation (2-3 sentences)
3. Opt-in copy: Headline, Subheadline, Bullets, Form fields, CTA button, Line under button
4. Assumptions and risks: what you guessed and what to test first.

Example output

At a glanceLead magnet ideas by total scoreCreation time plus offer fit, each scored out of 5
  • Etsy Fee and Profit Calculator: 9
  • Month-End Close Checklist: 9
  • Quarterly Tax Set-Aside Template: 8
  • 5-Day Email Course on Clean Books: 7
  • Is Your Shop Actually Profitable? Quiz: 6

Example for: a freelance bookkeeper selling $300/month bookkeeping to Etsy sellers, 6 hours to build the magnet, traffic from Instagram and Etsy seller Facebook groups.

1. Lead Magnet Options

Lead magnetFormatCreation timeOffer fitTotalReason
Etsy Fee and Profit CalculatorCalculator (Google Sheet)459Shows true profit per item, the exact gap monthly bookkeeping closes
Month-End Close Checklist for Etsy ShopsChecklist549Fast to make; shows the work involved, nudging toward outsourcing
Quarterly Tax Set-Aside TemplateTemplate448Useful, but overlaps with what tax preparers give away
"Is Your Shop Actually Profitable?" QuizQuiz246Good for social shares, but takes longer to build and tune
5-Day Email Course on Clean BooksMini-course257Strong fit, but 5 emails exceed the 6-hour budget

2. Recommendation

Build the Etsy Fee and Profit Calculator. It ties with the checklist on total, but its offer fit is higher: sellers who see their real margin after listing, transaction and ad fees are the ones who want someone to track it every month.

3. Opt-In Page Copy

Headline: See Your Real Profit on Every Etsy Sale

Subheadline: A free Google Sheet that subtracts every Etsy fee, shipping cost and ad spend so you know what you actually keep.

Bullets:

  • Enter a sale price and see listing, transaction and payment fees calculated for you
  • Spot which products lose money once Etsy Ads and shipping are counted
  • Find the price you need to hit your target margin
  • Get a monthly summary tab you can hand to your accountant at tax time

Form fields: First name, Email

CTA button: Get My Free Calculator

Line under button: Sent to your inbox in under a minute. Unsubscribe anytime.

4. Assumptions and Risks

  • I assumed most of your buyers sell physical goods; digital sellers have different costs, so add a toggle or a second tab.
  • Etsy fee rates change; date the sheet and check rates before launch.
  • Test first: the headline against "Stop Guessing Your Etsy Profit Margin" in Instagram link traffic.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Scoring on creation time and offer fit stops you from building a popular freebie that attracts people who will never buy.
  • Asking hours available and traffic source first keeps ideas realistic for your budget and channel.
  • Hard copy limits (12-word headline, verb-first CTA) produce page text you can publish without trimming.

Use when you have a paid product or service but a small email list. Paste into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and have your offer, price, buyer and available hours ready to answer the four questions.

Common edits

  • Ask for 3 headline variations to A/B test instead of one.
  • Add a request for a 3-email welcome sequence that delivers the lead magnet and introduces the paid offer.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Marketing