Write a Win-Back Email Campaign for Inactive Subscribers with a Sunset Rule

Get a 3-4 email re-engagement sequence built on your own inactivity data, ending in a sunset email and a clear rule for which subscribers to remove.

You getInactivity definition and segment rule, table and full copy per email

Prompt

Prompt
You are an email marketing manager who specializes in list hygiene and deliverability.

Your job: write a win-back campaign for my inactive subscribers. First ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. What do you send or sell, and how often do you email?
2. How do you define inactive (for example, no clicks in 90 days), and how many subscribers fit?
3. What can you offer to win them back (discount, freebie, content, fewer emails)?
4. Which email platform do you use?

Rules:
- Base the inactivity window on my answers; flag it if it covers fewer than three of my send cycles.
- Write 3-4 emails, each under 150 words with one call to action.
- Give two subject lines per email, under 50 characters, no fake "Re:" or all caps.
- Judge re-engagement by clicks, since Apple Mail Privacy Protection inflates opens.
- The final email is a plain sunset email with a one-click "keep me subscribed" link.

Output format:
1. Inactivity definition and segment rule
2. Table: Email | Day | Goal | Subject lines
3. Full copy per email: preview text, body, button text
4. Removal rule: who gets suppressed, when, and how to tag them
5. What to measure after 30 days

End with one line on assumptions made or data I should check.

Example output

At a glanceFour-email win-back sequence with sunsetRidgeline Roasters: 4,200 of 18,000 subscribers inactive 120 days
  1. Email 1: Remind them what they getDay 0Still brewing with us?
  2. Email 2: Give a reason to clickDay 415% off with code COMEBACK15
  3. Email 3: Offer fewer emailsDay 9Switch to a monthly roundup
  4. Email 4: SunsetDay 14Should we stop emailing you?
  5. Removal ruleDay 21No click: tag and move to suppression list

Example for: Ridgeline Roasters, a small coffee shop sending a weekly newsletter on Klaviyo, 4,200 of 18,000 subscribers with no clicks in 120 days, offering 15% off.

1. Inactivity definition

Inactive = no clicks in 120 days (about 17 weekly sends) and no order in 180 days. Exclude anyone who joined in the last 30 days.

2. Send schedule

EmailDayGoalSubject lines
10Remind them what they get"Still brewing with us?" / "Your coffee list misses you"
24Give a reason to click"15% off your next bag" / "A thank-you bag, on us-ish"
39Offer fewer emails"Too many emails? Pick less" / "Monthly instead of weekly?"
414Sunset"Should we stop emailing you?" / "Last email unless you click"

3. Email copy

Email 1 - Preview: New single-origins landed this month.
Hi there, it's been a while. Since you last visited we added an Ethiopian Guji and a decaf that actually tastes like coffee. Take a look at what's roasting this week.
Button: See this week's roasts

Email 2 - Preview: Code expires in 7 days.
We'd like you back, so here's 15% off any bag with code COMEBACK15. Valid for 7 days, one use.
Button: Use my 15% off

Email 3 - Preview: One click to change how often we write.
If weekly is too much, switch to a monthly roundup with new releases only.
Button: Switch to monthly

Email 4 (sunset) - Preview: No hard feelings either way.
We only want to email people who want to hear from us. Click below to stay. If we don't hear from you, we'll remove you on the 28th.
Button: Keep me subscribed

4. Removal rule

Anyone with no click across all 4 emails by day 21 gets tagged sunset-2024-q3 in Klaviyo and moved to a suppression list. Do not delete them, so they can't be re-imported by mistake.

5. Measure after 30 days

  • Click rate per email (target 2-4% for this segment)
  • Number re-engaged vs. suppressed
  • Revenue from COMEBACK15
  • Spam complaint rate on the main list (keep under 0.1%)
  • Main-list click rate before vs. after

Assumption: purchase data syncs to Klaviyo; check that buyers aren't wrongly marked inactive.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for your own inactivity window and send frequency keeps the segment realistic instead of a generic 90-day rule.
  • Judging by clicks, not opens, avoids false signals from Apple Mail Privacy Protection.
  • A sunset email plus a suppression rule protects sender reputation instead of mailing dead addresses forever.

Use when open and click rates are sliding or before a big send. Have your send frequency, inactive count and an offer ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Swap the discount for a free guide or content offer if you don't sell products.
  • Ask for a 2-email version for small lists or tight schedules.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Marketing