Synthesize interview panel notes into a hiring consensus

Compare disparate panel notes, map evaluations against shared scorecard criteria, and highlight hiring risks. Use this before debrief sessions to reach a sound decision.

You getCandidate Summary, pillar Evaluation Table and points of Contradiction

Prompt

Prompt
You are an executive talent partner synthesizing candidate interview feedback.
- Map the notes against the scorecard criteria they mention. If none are given, use these four: technical ability, problem solving, cross-functional collaboration, and role-specific leadership.
- Extract agreements and contradictions between interviewers.
- Highlight unresolved questions or red flags that need group discussion.
- Report only what interviewers wrote, using neutral language. Do not add your own opinions or scores, and ignore comments not tied to job-relevant evidence.
Output format:
- Candidate Summary: 2 sentences on overall impression
- Pillar Evaluation Table: Columns for Pillar, Overall Signal, Supporting Observations
- Points of Contradiction: bulleted differences in interviewer scores
- Key Debrief Questions: 3 targeted questions to reach consensus

Interview notes are pasted below:

Example output

Example for: panel notes for a Senior Systems Architect candidate

Candidate Summary: Strong distributed systems background with broad panel alignment on core architecture competencies. Hesitation centers on cross-team communication style and past experience managing external stakeholder expectations.

Pillar Evaluation Table:

PillarOverall SignalSupporting Observations
Technical AbilityStrong HireClean system design diagramming; accurately addressed edge cases around database replication lag.
Problem SolvingHireDeconstructed throughput bottlenecks effectively during the live coding scenario.
CollaborationMixedArchitectural lead praised technical clarity; product manager felt trade-offs were explained dismissively.
Role LeadershipLeaning HireDemonstrated solid mentorship examples, but limited examples of driving consensus through executive pushback.

Points of Contradiction:

  • Interviewer 1 noted outstanding clarity in explaining data models, while Interviewer 3 felt candidate was overly defensive when asked to justify architectural trade-offs.
  • Interviewer 2 rated leadership as top percentile based on past mentoring, whereas Interviewer 4 rated leadership neutral due to lack of cross-functional roadmapping examples.

Key Debrief Questions:

  1. Did the defensive responses observed in the product round indicate an everyday communication concern or an isolated interview stress reaction?
  2. Is our current scope demanding high executive influence immediately, or can mentoring within the platform team satisfy the role's needs?
  3. Would any panelist change their recommendation to a definitive Hire or No Hire based on the product manager's notes?
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste the debrief feedback from all interviewers into Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini. If interviewers used numeric rating scales, ask the model to include a summary column for individual scores.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Meetings & Notes