Should This Be an Agent? Single Agent, Workflow or Plain Script Decision
Scores a task you want to automate on variability, tool needs, error tolerance and cost, then recommends a plain script, a fixed LLM workflow, a single agent or multi-agent, with the cheapest first build.
You geta score table, the recommendation with reasons, the cheapest version to build first (steps and tools), what evidence would justify moving up a level, and 3 checks with pass…
The prompt
mkdir -p .agents/skills/should-this-be-an-agent-single-agent-workflow-or-plain-script-de && curl -sL "https://prompts-gpt.com/prompts/should-this-be-an-agent-single-agent-workflow-or-plain-script-decision/raw" -o .agents/skills/should-this-be-an-agent-single-agent-workflow-or-plain-script-de/SKILL.mdAct as a pragmatic AI engineer who prefers the simplest thing that works. Help me decide how to automate this task: Triage inbound customer refund emails for our online kitchenware store: read the email, look up the order in Shopify, decide if it qualifies under our 30-day refund policy, and draft a reply in Zendesk. (example value for {describe the task and its inputs})
If I have not said, ask me first in one message: how often it runs and at what volume, what happens when it gets something wrong, which tools or systems it must touch, and what a run may cost.
Score the task 1-5 on: how much the steps vary from case to case, how much it needs tools or live data, how much error it can tolerate, and how sensitive it is to cost and latency. Explain each score in one line.
Then recommend one of: a plain script or rules, a fixed LLM workflow (set steps with model calls), a single agent with tools, or multi-agent.
Rules: start from the simplest level and justify every step up; choose multi-agent only if one agent clearly cannot hold the context or the work truly runs in parallel; say where a human should approve.
Output format: a score table, the recommendation with reasons, the cheapest version to build first (steps and tools), what evidence would justify moving up a level, and 3 checks with pass thresholds that prove the choice works. List your assumptions and the risks of getting this wrong.Dashed parts are example values, so the prompt runs as copied. Change them in Fill in the blanks.
Example output
Paste into Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini before you start building. Describe a real task with examples of inputs; vague tasks get vague scores.
Keep exploring
More like this
Design an AI Agent With Tools, Guardrails and Eval Cases Before You Build It
Turns an agent idea into a build-ready design: the job, the tools with their inputs and permissions, guardrails, failure handling and a set of evaluation cases to test it.
20-Case Agent Eval Set with Pass/Fail Rubric for Normal, Edge and Unsafe Requests
Builds 20 test cases for your agent's task, with expected behavior, failure signals and a pass/fail rubric covering normal, edge and unsafe requests.
Agent Tool Names, Descriptions and JSON Schemas from API Docs
Turns pasted API docs or a function list into agent-ready tool names, descriptions, JSON input schemas and when-to-use and when-not-to-use notes.
Coding Agent Task Brief with Guardrails, Test Plan, and Rollback Steps
Creates a scoped brief for an AI coding agent that limits file changes, defines tests, and includes a rollback plan and review checklist.
Research Agent Brief: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table
Directs an AI agent to plan source discovery, grade evidence, build a citation table, and support a decision without claiming live browsing occurred.
Tool Permission Matrix and Function Spec for a Tool-Using Agent
Produces a least-privilege tool inventory, function definitions, and approval rules for an agent that calls APIs or internal systems.
- Agent Run Pre-Mortem and Self-Correction Loop Designer
- Agent Workflow Decomposition with Autonomy Levels and Stop Rules
- Checkable Guardrail Rules for a Coding Agent: Blocked Commands, Approvals, Secrets and Hooks
- Codebase Tour for a Specific Task
- Research, Writer and Editor Agent Pipeline With a Handoff Schema
- Headless Claude Code Script for CI: claude -p Task With Exit Codes and Output Checks