Evidence Review Plan for a Classroom Teaching Strategy Decision

Guides source discovery, evidence review, a citation table, synthesis, and a recommendation on whether to adopt a teaching strategy. It does not claim live browsing and marks every unverified item for you to check.

You get: Search plan table, evidence extraction table and citation table

More like this

The prompt

evidence-review-plan-for-a-classroom-teaching-strategy-decision.md
Role: You are an education research analyst who helps teachers and school leaders evaluate teaching strategies.Context: I am deciding whether to adopt {strategy} for {audience} in {setting}. The decision this must support: adopt, pilot, or do not adopt, and under what conditions.
Task: Produce a source discovery plan, an evidence review framework, a citation table template or entries, a synthesis, and a decision recommendation.Constraints: Do not claim you browsed the web or accessed sources unless I paste the text or your tool shows search results in this conversation. Do not invent citations, authors, statistics, or URLs. If you recall a source from memory, label it Unverified and tell me how to confirm it. Separate what is known, what is assumed, and what is missing.

Inputs
- Strategy or intervention: {strategy}
- Population and setting: {audience}, {setting}
- Outcome that matters: {outcome}
- Decision deadline and cost or time limits: {deadline}, {constraints}
- Sources I already have (paste excerpts or titles): {existing_sources}
- Evidence standard I need (for example peer-reviewed studies, meta-analyses, practitioner reports): {evidence_standard}

Workflow
1. Check inputs. If strategy, population, or outcome is missing, ask up to 5 questions and stop.
2. Source discovery plan: give 5 to 8 search queries, with databases and site types to use, such as Google Scholar, ERIC, education agency evidence clearinghouses, and journals, plus inclusion and exclusion criteria. State that I must run these searches myself unless your tool has search enabled and shows its results.
3. Evidence review: for each source I provide, extract design, sample, setting, outcome measure, effect or finding, limitations, and relevance to my context. Mark fields not stated in the source as Not reported.
4. Citation table: build the table with a Verification status column (Provided by user, Search result shown, Unverified recall).
5. Synthesis: summarize agreement, conflicts, strength of evidence, and applicability to {setting}.
6. Decision support: give a recommendation (Adopt, Pilot, or Do not adopt), conditions, and a pilot design with success measures if relevant.
7. List risks, missing evidence, and next actions.

Output format
1. Assumptions and missing information
2. Search plan table (Query | Where to search | Purpose | Inclusion or exclusion note)
3. Evidence extraction table (Source | Design | Sample | Outcome | Finding | Limitations | Relevance)
4. Citation table (Citation | Verification status | Notes)
5. Synthesis (Consistent findings | Conflicts | Evidence strength | Fit to my setting)
6. Recommendation and conditions
7. Pilot plan and success measures (if applicable)
8. Risks, evidence gaps, next actions

Acceptance criteria
- No citation appears without a verification status.
- No claim is attributed to a source that I did not provide unless labeled Unverified.
- The recommendation links directly to findings and to my context.
- Limitations and evidence gaps are explicit.
- Next actions are specific and doable within {deadline}.

Quality checks
Before answering, scan for invented details, confirm every table row is traceable, confirm the recommendation matches the evidence strength, and state what you could not verify.

Tool notes: In Perplexity or ChatGPT with search enabled, run the search plan and list the sources actually returned, with links shown by the tool; do not add any not returned. In Claude or Gemini without search, use only pasted text or uploaded files and produce the search plan for me to execute. If using document upload, ask for page references in each extraction row.

Example output

AI-written example

1. Assumptions and missing information

  • Strategy: low-stakes retrieval practice quizzes (5 to 10 min, start of lesson). Audience: Year 9 science students. Setting: one public secondary school, mixed-ability classes.
  • Outcome: end-of-unit test scores. Deadline: 3 weeks, no budget, 10 min per lesson.
  • Evidence standard: systematic reviews or controlled studies preferred, with practitioner reports as supporting evidence.
  • Missing: the pilot's test design, the class sizes, and whether the teachers differed.
  • I have not browsed. I can only use the pasted text.

2. Search plan (you run these)

QueryWherePurposeNote
"retrieval practice" secondary scienceERIC, Google ScholarCore studiesInclude ages 12-15
"testing effect" classroom randomizedGoogle ScholarCausal evidenceExclude lab-only, university samples
retrieval practice meta-analysis schoolERICPooled effectsPeer-reviewed only
low-stakes quizzing adolescentsJournalsApplicabilityInclude outcomes beyond tests
retrieval practice evidence summaryEducation agency clearinghousesPractitioner synthesisNote publication date

3. Evidence extraction

SourceDesignSampleOutcomeFindingLimitationsRelevance
Dept memo, Y9 Chemistry pilotTwo-class comparisonNot reportedUnit test %Quiz class 68% vs 61%No randomization, no baseline, one teacher (Not reported)High setting match, low rigor

4. Citation table

CitationVerification statusNotes
Y9 Chemistry pilot memo (internal)Provided by userRequest raw scores
Roediger & Karpicke (2006), testing effectUnverified recallSearch the authors and title in Google Scholar and check the journal and year
Dunlosky et al. (2013), learning techniques reviewUnverified recallConfirm via the journal site or Google Scholar

5. Synthesis

  • Consistent: the only verified source favors quizzing.
  • Conflicts: none found, but only one source was reviewed.
  • Strength: weak (verified) because the memo is uncontrolled. Recalled sources may strengthen this once confirmed.
  • Fit: the memo matches your setting but cannot show the effect was caused by the quizzes.

6. Recommendation: Pilot
Conditions: confirm the two recalled sources and check the memo's baseline data. Adoption is not justified by evidence you have verified so far.

7. Pilot plan

  • Four Year 9 classes over one unit, two with quizzes and two without, with a shared unit test.
Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Use this before changing a practice or buying a program. Run the searches yourself or confirm that your tool actually shows results, then paste excerpts back for extraction. Verify every citation before sharing the conclusion.

Questions about this prompt

More in Education

Competitor Landscape Research Plan with Source Discovery and Citation Table

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence review, citation table, and decision-ready synthesis for a competitor or market question, without pretending live browsing occurred.

Productivity Tool Selection: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table

A research workflow to choose between candidate productivity or automation tools. It plans online source discovery, structures evidence review in a citation table, and ends in a decision memo without claiming live browsing took place.

Competitor Landscape Scan with Source-Backed Citation Table

Runs a structured competitor scan that starts with search queries, ranks sources by reliability, and ends with a cited comparison table and a positioning recommendation.

Competitor UX Pattern Research Plan with Evidence Table and Design Recommendation

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence log, citation table, and synthesis for comparing UX patterns across competitors, without claiming live browsing.

Parallel Research Fan-Out and Fan-In with Citation Table and Decision Memo

Splits a research question across parallel research agents, defines source discovery and evidence review steps, merges findings into a citation table, and produces a decision memo without claiming live browsing.

Research Agent Brief: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table

Directs an AI agent to plan source discovery, grade evidence, build a citation table, and support a decision without claiming live browsing occurred.

Audience Research Source Discovery and Evidence Synthesis for Segment Prioritization

Guides you to plan source discovery, review the evidence you collect, build a citation table, and synthesize findings into a segment prioritization decision, without pretending the model browsed the web.

AI Paper Explainer with Evidence Table and Practical Takeaways

Turns a pasted AI paper abstract or text into a plain-language explanation of what is new, how it was tested, its limits and what to do with it.

Competitor and Audience Evidence Review with Citation Table and Go/No-Go Brief

A research workflow that plans online source discovery, scores evidence, builds a citation table, and ends with a decision brief, without pretending live browsing happened.

Two-to-Three Model Comparison Test Plan with 10 Prompts and Scoring Rubric

Creates a side-by-side test plan for choosing an AI model for your use case, with 10 test prompts, a scoring rubric and a blank results table.

60-Minute Lesson Plan with Checks for Understanding and Differentiation

Builds a timed, objective-aligned lesson plan with formative checks, differentiation, and a teach-or-revise readiness verdict. It asks for missing inputs first and keeps assumptions separate.

Adaptive Quiz from My Notes with Weak-Spot Summary

Quizzes you one question at a time from your own notes, adjusts difficulty after each answer, and ends with a ranked list of weak spots.