Prepare constructive feedback for a defensive top performer
Turn observed collaboration issues into a direct, objective conversation guide that prevents defensiveness and sets clear behavioral standards.
You getMeeting Opening Script, the Core Issue and handling Defensiveness
Prompt
Act as an experienced executive coach helping a manager deliver tough feedback to an employee who delivers great individual work but dismisses peers or resists critique.
- Separate hard results from interpersonal impact using clear, factual observations.
- Draft an opening script that acknowledges their technical strengths without blunting the core performance issue.
- Include three anticipated defensive reactions and word-for-word calming redirects.
- Specify one clear behavioral expectation and a two-week follow-up checkpoint.
Output format:
1. Meeting Opening Script
2. The Core Issue (Situation, Behavior, Impact)
3. Handling Defensiveness (3 objections and manager responses)
4. Agreed Next Steps & Check-in Date
Notes on the employee and recent incidents are below:Example output
Paste your rough notes about recent interactions after the prompt in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. As a follow-up, ask the model to roleplay the conversation with you so you can practice your delivery.
Make it repeatable
Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.
Prompt details
- By
- Prompts-GPT editors
- Published
Did this prompt work?
Keep exploring
More like this
Build a thirty-sixty-ninety day onboarding plan
Generate a clear, phased milestone roadmap for incoming team members to eliminate ambiguity. Use this during hiring or early onboarding to set transparent expectations.
Practice a tough feedback talk via role-play
Role-play delivering difficult constructive feedback to a direct report who pushes back, makes excuses, or shuts down.
Diagnose sudden underperformance in a coaching conversation
Plan a structured, diagnostic 1:1 script when a dependable team member's performance suddenly drops. Identifies root causes without jumping to conclusions.
Deliver a fair promotion deferral with clear milestones
Turn a difficult promotion deferral conversation into a transparent plan with concrete milestones, maintaining trust and retention.
Separate confirmed reorg facts from open leadership questions
Turn messy reorg briefings into clear lists of confirmed changes and open unknowns to share with your team. Use this when organizational announcements leave your direct reports confused.
Set team communication norms to stop after-hours work
Establish clear communication guardrails that protect personal time without slowing down urgent operational needs. Use this to reduce team burnout and reset expectations around late-night pings.