Peer and Direct-Report Feedback for Review Season Using Specific Examples
Writes review-form answers about a colleague or report from your own dated examples, using situation-behavior-impact, with one strength, one growth area and a check that flags vague or unsupported lines.
You getAn answer under each form question, strength and growth area summary and check table
The prompt
You are an experienced manager who writes fair, specific performance feedback. Help me write review feedback about a colleague using only the examples I give you.
Their role and my relationship to them (peer, direct report or manager): senior backend engineer, my direct report (example value for {their role and our relationship})
Review form questions, rating scale and 3-6 dated examples: Q1 Key contributions, Q2 Areas to grow; scale 1-5; Mar: led the billing migration with zero downtime; Jul: missed two design review deadlines (example value for {form questions scale and examples})
Rules:
- Never invent examples, numbers or outcomes. If a question has no supporting example, write "Needs an example" instead of filling it.
- Use situation, behavior, impact for each point: what happened, what they did, what changed because of it.
- Give one clear strength and one growth area, each tied to an example, with a concrete next step for the growth area.
- Write direct sentences without hedging words (maybe, a bit, sometimes) and describe behavior, not personality.
- Suggest a rating only if I gave a scale, and name the examples that support it.
Output format:
1. An answer under each form question
2. Strength and growth area summary
3. Check table: sentence | issue (vague praise, personality judgment, no example, possible bias) | suggested fix
Note any example that seems too thin to rely on.Dashed parts are example values, so the prompt runs as copied. Change them in Fill in the blanks.
Example output
For year-end reviews in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Paste the form questions and your rough notes with dates. Remove names or confidential details if your company policy requires it.
Keep exploring
More like this
Prepare a One-on-One Meeting Agenda and Questions for a Direct Report
You get a timed one-on-one agenda that starts with your report's topics, includes wins, blockers and growth questions, and ends with a follow-up tracker from last time.
Performance Review Self-Assessment Built From Your Actual Wins
Turns a messy list of what you did this year into a self-assessment organised by your company's review criteria, with impact stated plainly and one honest growth area.
Live Mock Interviewer That Scores Each Answer 1-5
Run a realistic one-question-at-a-time mock interview for your role and company, with a score and one concrete fix after every answer.
Explain a Contract Clause in Plain English and What It Means for You
Paste one contract clause and get a line-by-line plain-English translation, vague terms flagged, a worst-case example, and three questions to ask the other side.
Organize Business Receipts and Records into a Bookkeeping-Ready Filing System
You get a folder tree, a file naming rule with examples, a records retention table and a timed 15-minute weekly routine built around your own tools and expenses.
Turn Health Inspection Notes into a Ranked Fix Plan with Owners and Deadlines
Paste your inspection report or notes and get every finding ranked by risk and cost, with an owner, a deadline, prevention checks and when to call a pro.