Peer and Direct-Report Feedback for Review Season Using Specific Examples

Writes review-form answers about a colleague or report from your own dated examples, using situation-behavior-impact, with one strength, one growth area and a check that flags vague or unsupported lines.

You getAn answer under each form question, strength and growth area summary and check table

The prompt

Prompt
You are an experienced manager who writes fair, specific performance feedback. Help me write review feedback about a colleague using only the examples I give you.

Their role and my relationship to them (peer, direct report or manager): senior backend engineer, my direct report (example value for {their role and our relationship})
Review form questions, rating scale and 3-6 dated examples: Q1 Key contributions, Q2 Areas to grow; scale 1-5; Mar: led the billing migration with zero downtime; Jul: missed two design review deadlines (example value for {form questions scale and examples})

Rules:
- Never invent examples, numbers or outcomes. If a question has no supporting example, write "Needs an example" instead of filling it.
- Use situation, behavior, impact for each point: what happened, what they did, what changed because of it.
- Give one clear strength and one growth area, each tied to an example, with a concrete next step for the growth area.
- Write direct sentences without hedging words (maybe, a bit, sometimes) and describe behavior, not personality.
- Suggest a rating only if I gave a scale, and name the examples that support it.

Output format:
1. An answer under each form question
2. Strength and growth area summary
3. Check table: sentence | issue (vague praise, personality judgment, no example, possible bias) | suggested fix

Note any example that seems too thin to rely on.

Dashed parts are example values, so the prompt runs as copied. Change them in Fill in the blanks.

Example output

At a glanceStrength vs growth area for DanaTwo dated examples, each with a suggested rating and next step
ItemStrengthGrowth area
ExampleMar: billing migrationJul: two missed design review deadlines
SummaryHigh-risk work without service disruptionDesign documents arrived after review dates
Suggested rating4 / 53 / 5
Next stepWrite up migration approach as a templateFlag slip risk 3 business days ahead

Example for: a senior backend engineer who reports to me, with two dated examples (March billing migration, July missed design review deadlines).

1. Form Answers

Q1 – Key contributions

In March, Dana led the migration of our billing system to the new platform (situation). She owned the cutover plan and coordinated the move from start to finish (behavior). The migration completed with zero downtime, so customers saw no billing interruption during the switch (impact).

Suggested rating: 4 / 5. Supporting example: March billing migration. One high-impact project supports an above-expectations score. A 5 needs more examples showing this level across the full review period.

Q2 – Areas to grow

In July, two design reviews were scheduled with deadlines for Dana's design documents (situation). Dana missed both deadlines (behavior). The examples do not record what changed as a result. Needs an example of the impact: delayed decisions, blocked teammates, or a slipped ship date.

Suggested rating: 3 / 5. Supporting example: July missed deadlines. Two misses in one month show a pattern worth addressing, but they don't establish a trend across the year.

2. Strength and Growth Area Summary

ExampleSummaryNext step
StrengthMar: billing migrationPlans and executes high-risk technical work without service disruption.Ask Dana to write up the migration approach as a template for future cutovers.
Growth areaJul: two missed design review deadlinesDesign documents arrived after agreed review dates.Before each design review, Dana flags any slip risk to me at least 3 business days ahead and proposes a new date. We review progress in 1:1s for the next quarter.

3. Check Table

SentenceIssueSuggested fix
"She owned the cutover plan and coordinated the move from start to finish."No example. The input says "led" but gives no detail on what leading involved.Add one specific action, e.g., the rollback plan she wrote or the dry run she ran.
"So customers saw no billing interruption."No example. This assumes customer impact from "zero downtime."Confirm with incident or support data, or cut back to "with zero downtime."
"Dana missed both deadlines."No example. There is no cause or impact.Add what the delay affected and whether Dana communicated it in advance.
"Two misses in one month show a pattern."Possible bias. This is a recency risk, because July may outweigh the rest of the year.Check Jan–Jun and Aug onward for on-time design work before finalizing.

Thin examples: Both examples are single lines. The July example has no stated impact or context, such as competing priorities or a reassignment. Do not rely on it for a rating until you add those details. With only two examples, you need 1–4 more dated examples to meet the 3–6 range and to support either rating with confidence.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

For year-end reviews in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Paste the form questions and your rough notes with dates. Remove names or confidential details if your company policy requires it.

Keep exploring

More in Business