Internal promotion rejection talking points and email

Deliver disappointing promotion news to an internal employee with constructive framing that protects their engagement and outlines a development path.

You get1-on-1 Meeting Guide and follow-Up Summary Email

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an experienced hiring manager. Create a spoken talking points outline and a follow-up email to notify a valued internal candidate that they were not selected for a promotion.

Rules:
- Lead with clarity: share the decision immediately without stalling.
- Give honest, constructive feedback contrasting current skills with the selected candidate's profile, without disclosing confidential peer details.
- Affirm their value to the team to mitigate retention and morale risks.
- Propose concrete development actions or high-visibility projects to bridge the gap.

Output format:
1. 1-on-1 Meeting Guide (Bullet points: Decision, Positive Feedback, Gap Analysis, Retention/Forward Look)
2. Follow-Up Summary Email (Written to the employee)

The employee background, the role applied for, and reasons for the decision are below:

Example output

Example for: a senior designer passed over for a Lead Product Designer role in favor of an external hire

1. 1-on-1 Meeting Guide
  • Decision: Share the outcome immediately. "Thank you for your patience during this process. We have made an offer to another candidate for the Lead Product Designer role, and I wanted to talk through this with you directly before any broad announcement."
  • Positive Feedback: Validate their strong performance. Point specifically to their exceptional craft on the checkout redesign and their trusted standing among the front-end engineers.
  • Gap Analysis: Explain the specific differentiator without comparing them unfavorably. "The new role requires multi-quarter design system governance and direct people management experience across distributed squads, which was the deciding factor."
  • Retention and Forward Look: Outline clear growth opportunities. "You are an essential pillar of this product team. I want to build a targeted plan over the next two quarters where you take ownership of mentoring our associate designer and lead the quarterly roadmap critique."
2. Follow-Up Summary Email

Subject: Follow-up from our 1-on-1 | Career development discussion

Hi Sarah,

Thank you for our open conversation earlier today. While I know this was not the outcome you hoped for regarding the Lead Product Designer position, I want to reiterate how much I value your craft, your delivery, and your leadership within our squad.

As discussed, our focus over the next two quarters will be expanding your scope into design systems leadership and cross-functional mentoring. Let's use our regular bi-weekly sync next Tuesday to draft two specific development goals that align with this path.

I appreciate your hard work and look forward to partnering closely on your continued growth here.

Best,
David

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste the candidate's current role, target role, and interview feedback after the prompt in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Follow up by asking the model to prepare answers to difficult questions the candidate might ask during the call.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in HR & Management